‘Too much to lose’
The systems that keep exploited migrants silent
Back to report home page Download PDF
Nothing can be done, in Australia – they just want to keep us silent and punish for speaking up.
19-year-old Indian woman arrived in 2023 to study at a Queensland university, while working as a waitress was paid $14 per hour, always in cash

4,835 survey participants knew they had been underpaid. Only one in seven (14%) managed to take steps to recover their wages.

Speaking up could cost a worker their shifts, their job or their visa. Reporting systems don’t deliver results so for most it doesn’t make sense to speak up.

Background

This report is the second in a series presenting findings from the National Temporary Migrant Work Survey of almost 10,000 migrants across Australia. Off the Books: Inside Australia’s Hidden System of Migrant Worker Exploitation revealed that, for most migrant workers, underpayment has become the expected price of a job. Two in three migrant employees were unlawfully underpaid. More than one in three migrants were engaged on an ABN with no employee records.

The Fair Work Ombudsman is principally responsible for enforcing the Fair Work Act. However, in reality, enforcement largely relies on underpaid migrants taking proactive action against their employer. This includes demanding outstanding wages from their employer, reporting to the FWO or corporate grievance mechanisms, joining a union, or lodging a claim in court.

This report shows the systems failure that has left migrant exploitation unchecked.

01

Underpayment of migrant workers goes unchallenged 86% of the time. This report sets out to understand why.

Only one in seven migrants who knew they were underpaid took any action to get their unpaid wages from their employer.

For the overwhelming majority of survey participants, the costs and risks of engaging with any enforcement channels were too great.

3%of underpaid migrants had approached the Fair Work Ombudsman, even though 59% of them knew about the FWO
4%of underpaid migrants had raised the issue of unpaid wages with a supervisor or human resource officer
<1%sought help from a union or community legal centre
17out of 4,835 underpaid participants went to court
02

The worst violations are the least likely to generate a complaint.

Migrants do not stay silent because the underpayment is not significant. Our data shows migrants who were owed the most were the least likely to act. Workers paid less than $20 an hour in their lowest paid job (and who were the most underpaid per hour) were the least likely to try to recover unpaid wages.

For businesses and regulators, this means the workplaces with the worst violations are least likely to be proactively brought to their attention.

03

The problem is not lack of awareness: structural barriers keep exploited migrants silent.

We asked 3,031 migrants who knew they were underpaid why they would not try to recover the wages they were owed. The barriers they reported were overwhelmingly structural.

Migrants’ silence is a rational response to a system that makes speaking up too risky, too hard and unlikely to pay off.

Many of the same factors that make migrants vulnerable to exploitation also keep those workers silent. The barriers clustered around five key themes. Most migrants identified more than one.

Select each barrier to read more

{{ barCur.title }}

{{ barCur.sub }}

{{ barCur.stat }}{{ barCur.statLabel }}

{{ barCur.b1 }}

{{ barCur.b2 }}

What needs to change

Taking steps to address wage theft must be made safe and worthwhile for migrant workers.

Responsibility for enforcing Australian workplace laws should principally be borne by government. It should not primarily depend on large numbers of migrant workers proactively seeking to hold exploitative employers to account.

To make speaking up rational for migrant workers, Government and other stakeholders should invest in structural reforms across three key areas.

First

The Commonwealth Government should ensure it is safe and practicable for exploited migrants to speak up, and pathways for addressing underpayment are accessible and deliver outcomes.

Second

The Commonwealth Government should invest in institutional frameworks that enforce the law at the scale the problem demands. There must be a realistic expectation that exploitative employers will be caught and pay a serious price.

I think the government has not taken enough action for the employers who pay the illegal pay ... Why? Because we are just temporary visa holder.
I know our right, but i have no any energy and power to fight for my right.
i will lost my job if i try to say anything for the legal pay. If government don’t take the action, why you expect the employee will take the action?
31-year-old male international student from Hong Kong in SA
Third

Responsibility must be shared. Government holds primary responsibility for addressing workplace exploitation, but other actors should better leverage their power.

Companies that benefit from underpaid migrant labour in their operations and supply chains should bear responsibility for identifying and addressing underpayment rather than wait for it to be reported. Universities and colleges have direct, ongoing relationships with international students and can provide critical timely support to address underpayment. Unions, whose members were almost twice as likely to act, can reach more migrant workers in the industries where exploitation is concentrated.

If the Government, businesses and other stakeholders continue to engage in the same strategies that tinker around the edges of this problem, silence will remain the rational choice for most underpaid migrants. Wage theft will remain cost-free for the businesses that profit from it.

Summary of recommendations

To the Commonwealth Government

01

Reform migration settings linked to exploitation

Strengthen and expand access to the visa protection pilots, reduce reliance on employer sponsorship for visa pathways, ensure labour enforcement accompanies immigration enforcement and consider increasing student working hour cap.

02

Mobilise cross-government regulatory levers to scale labour enforcement

Invest in the Fair Work Ombudsman to operate at scale, including resources to address migrant sham contracting in particular, rigorously condition employer sponsorship of migrants on workplace compliance, and increase use of the Prohibited Employer Register to sanction employers that seriously breach the Fair Work Act.

03

Examine the exploitation of international students and develop a targeted response

Commission a systemic review of exploitation of international students, then establish a multi-government-agency response in collaboration with universities and the international education sector that includes establishment of university-linked legal support, accreditation of university legal services to access visa protections for exploited students, funding for the FWO to provide dedicated support to these services, and evidence-led development and delivery of workplace rights information.

04

Invest in migrant information and legal support

Evaluate gaps and increase funding for legal assistance for all migrant workers on temporary visas, establish a new wage and superannuation calculation assistance, and address migrant knowledge barriers to accessing justice.

05

Establish accessible wage recovery pathways

Establish accessible administrative and judicial wage-recovery forums (including a Fair Work Court) and introduce reforms that enable migrants to recover wages when the employer will not pay, disappears or liquidates.

06

Strengthen supply chain accountability

Introduce a corporate due diligence obligation for forced labour risks, consider accessorial liability expansion for underpayment and other workplace breaches in business operations and supply chains.

With State and Territory Governments

07

Leverage licensing schemes to drive workplace compliance

Introduce a national labour hire licensing scheme (or coordinated schemes across states and territories), leverage other licensing regimes to sanction employers that exploit migrant workers.

Read the full recommendations

In their words

{{ vqSel.text }}
{{ vqSel.by }}
Eleven migrants told us why they stayed silent. Click a blinking dot to read what one of them said.
University of Technology Sydney UNSW Sydney
UTS Law Faculty and UNSW Faculty of Law & Justice are proud supporters of the Migrant Justice Institute. MJI is a charity registered with ACNC. ABN 84654507758.
ACNC Registered Charity
Be the first to know when we publish new research

Get early access to new reports, hear about policy wins first, and stay connected to the fight for migrant worker justice.

Subscribe
Off The Books report cover ‘Right or wrong, just accept it’ report cover
Migrant Workers’ Access to Justice for Wage Theft report cover All Work, No Pay report cover
Migrant Justice Institute

The Migrant Justice Institute respectfully acknowledges the Gadigal and Bedegal peoples of the Eora Nation and the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nations, the traditional owners and custodians of the land on which we work. We pay our respects to their elders past and present and acknowledge that sovereignty was never ceded.

Contents