‘Too much to lose’
The systems that keep exploited migrants silent
Back to report home page Download PDF
05 Key findings

Barriers to action

Why the overwhelming majority of underpaid migrants are silenced

This section considers the responses of participants who indicated that they had been underpaid during their stay in Australia but had not tried to recover unpaid wages in relation to any job.

Recognising that significant passage of time can be an overwhelming barrier to taking action that eclipses all other barriers, we confined our analysis to those who had arrived within 2.5 years of the survey (2022 onwards) so the underpayment experience was relatively recent.

We asked participants what prevents them from trying to recover their unpaid wages and invited them to select one or more options from a randomised list of 19 potential barriers. We developed the list of barriers based on focus groups with different migrant cohorts, prior research, and feedback on the survey draft from migrants, employment law experts, unions and service providers (see our website for a detailed description of the research methods).27

63% of participants selected more than one barrier to explain why they had not tried to recover unpaid wages. This indicates that multiple factors generally operate together to silence these workers.

Where participants did not select a particular barrier this should not be interpreted as an affirmative indication that this barrier was not relevant to the participant. The questions on wage recovery appeared at the end of the survey when some participants may have been fatigued. Participants may not have selected an option because it was not front of mind or because they only selected the most significant barriers from within a high volume of options. Some participants may not have selected an option because another option was such an overwhelming barrier that other applicable barriers were not material. For example, despite the randomised order of barriers, visa fears stood out more than other barriers. For some participants, other potential barriers may have been so significantly eclipsed by visa fears that they were not material.

Participants did not rank or weigh the barriers and it is therefore unclear whether addressing any single barrier alone would change their decision. For example, over a third of migrants (38%) who indicated they did not ‘know where to go or what to do’ also cited problems with their visa as barriers to taking action. For some or many of these individuals, concerns about their visa may have prevented them from taking action even if they were given information about what to do. Similarly, even if they could access visa protections, they would likely still require information and assistance to seek redress.

This section examines the five key categories of reasons that 3,031 survey participants gave for their decision to remain silent in relation to unpaid wages. All of these participants arrived in Australia within 2.5 years of the survey and knew they had been underpaid.

1Employer leverage
Barrier 1 · Employer leverage

Employers wield control over migrants’ insecure jobs with unchecked retaliation opportunities

The number one barrier that would stop migrants from seeking to recover unpaid wages was ‘I don’t want to lose my job’. This was selected by one in three (32%) participants. This is likely still a substantial under-representation of the salience of this barrier because it was no longer relevant for participants who had already left the underpaid job at the time of the survey, but who may have remained silent for fear of losing their job when they were in that job.

Fear of job loss was raised by hundreds of participants in the open responses and is clearly the most common barrier to taking action while a migrant worker is in a job.

Fear of job loss can be a serious concern for Australian employees in general who are considering pursuing a wage claim. However, it is especially acute for workers on temporary visas because (a) there is a greater likelihood of actual job loss due to high rates of insecure work and replaceability of many workers in low-skilled jobs, and (b) the impact of losing work may be particularly acute for migrants. This is a result of several factors, including their more restricted labour market access, their increased financial dependence on work in the absence of social security or family safety nets, plus dependence on the job for immigration pathways, and for some, dependence on the income to re-pay debts. Each of these are explored below.

Migrant workers predominantly work in insecure jobs that can be easily terminated

As discussed in Off the Books, three quarters of participants were in insecure work arrangements in their lowest paid job in 2023-24, with 35% engaged as contractors on an ABN and 38% engaged as casual employees.28 These workers were the most underpaid.29

Many migrants perceive the tremendous leverage their employers wield. They are acutely aware that casual employees (and ABN workers) have no guaranteed hours, and their employer is able to retaliate against any undesirable worker conduct by rostering the worker on fewer or worse shifts, or no shifts at all.

Employers know we require the money and if we speak up they either reduce your shifts, make you do far worse work or fire you.
27-year-old female international student from India in VIC

Migrants whose employers disregard the Fair Work Act are heavily reliant on the good will of their employer for whatever they get paid, and for their ongoing ability to work in that job at all.

Migrants (especially the casual workers) are made to work like horse (double of full time and part time in terms of quantity and difficulties). When the migrants refuse to complete that task within the limited time, employers threaten of not giving job and the shift on regular basis (and sometimes does that).
34-year-old male international student from Bhutan in QLD

ABN workers generally lack protection against summary dismissal.30 Casual employees may in principle have general protections against adverse action by an employer for exercising industrial rights, however, numerous participants noted that employers can easily misattribute termination of casual employees to workflow, poor performance or other excuses.

The boss can change your shifts, or even you may lose your job since your boss can find a lot of excuses to do that.
33-year-old female international student from China in SA
I spoke with family and my colleagues but didnt feel anything could be done. If I reported it formally they likely would have said I dont work effectively and I could have lost my job. I needed a car for work and took out a loan so I couldnt afford to lose my job.
Female skilled visa holder, 41-years old from South Africa in NSW

An international student who worked as a waitress for $18 per hour on an ABN in 2023-24 (sometimes in cash) shared:

I am paid illegally but I am afraid if I go to fair work to ask for my wages, my boss will fire me than I got nothing
Female international student from China in VIC

Another international student who worked as a cleaner for $18 per hour on an ABN in 2023-24 shared:

I have been working at one of Child care since December 2023, and usually I got weekend shift as cleaner. They never paid me different wages. I don't know that I could claimed the wages that they owed. However I am afraid that I get fired.
35-year-old female international student from Indonesia in NSW

Numerous participants also pointed to higher standards expected of migrant workers compared with other workers in order to be given ongoing work. This included working additional unpaid hours or accepting heavier workloads in the same amount of time.

I sometimes feel that my mistakes are paid more attention compared to citizens. Also, when one of my co-worker used to touch me inappropriately, I was scared to complain as it would jeopardise my job. Sometimes the manager would shout at me and expect me to do more work beyond my working hours.
21-year-old female international student from India in NSW

Visa settings and other factors limit migrants’ ability to leave underpaid work and find a better job

In Off the Books, we presented findings on the obstacles that prevent migrant workers obtaining decent work.31 These include lack of local experience and connections in the Australian labour market that impede access to employment upon arrival, and limited visa duration that impedes access to work towards the end of a visa. Migrant workers with poorer English language skills face even greater barriers to accessing the labour market and may be confined to seeking less specialised jobs in which they are aware that they are easily replaceable.

As discussed below, the additional barrier to employability posed by international students’ 48-hour fortnightly work limitation was one of the most common themes expressed across survey open responses.

Student visa holders tend to compensate their rights just for keeping their jobs.
23-year-old male international student from Malaysia in TAS

Migrants’ financial precarity, debt, and lack of social security safety nets create dependence on maintaining their underpaid job

As discussed in detail in Off the Books, hundreds of participants underscored their dependence on their job for survival and coverage of basic living expenses.32 A common theme was rising cost of living that pushed expenses higher than the migrant had anticipated. International students in casual or ABN roles noted they could not refuse hours that would cause them to breach their 48-hour per fortnight work limitation because of the unpredictability of casual work, and their understanding that their work hours and income were at the complete discretion of their employer.

I feel that life of a migrant is so tough especially with regards to money. Lots of bills to pay but can't ask family back home. Though we know we are paid less, we can't complain. Job insecurity and less opportunities.
24-year-old male international student from India in VIC

The potential impact of losing their job or shifts was substantially amplified by their inability to access social security,33 with no other local safety net.

Workers have to accept the bad condition because of their situation and responsibilities toward family. And as a temporary you are not entitled to any social security.
30-year-old female Partner Visa holder from India in QLD

For a substantial number of participants, retaining their job and income was critical to paying off debt. This may have been debt to agents at home who had facilitated their journey to Australia and employment, debts for tuition fees, or credit card or other debts to cover living expenses.

Jobs that are too difficult, little time, little salary, studying and working is difficult but sometimes we must accept less salary than the normal and legal salary because we need to pay debts and it is better to have a low salary than to have no job.
28-year-old female student from Colombia who worked on an ABN in commercial cleaning in SA

Migrants’ visa or immigration pathway can be contingent on maintaining job

As discussed in the next sub-section, a substantial number of participants could not risk losing their job because it was tied to their stay in Australia and their immigration pathway. Some may have hoped their employer might sponsor them for a skilled visa, and others may have needed their job to obtain work experience required to apply for a future visa. As gatekeepers to migrants’ immigration pathways, employers wield significant leverage over workers, which is a significant deterrent to complaining or asserting rights.

When I was sponsored to work in Australia, I felt that I couldn't leave the job even though it was a toxic environment. My visa was tied to my employment, so I had to endure years of emotional hardship that affected my physical health. I left the job once I obtained a permanent residency.
44-year-old non-binary/ transgender Permanent Resident from Indonesia in VIC

Employer retaliation can extend beyond the migrant’s current job

If the migrant complains, the employer can retaliate by damaging the migrant’s reputation and future job prospects, especially within a community or small town

One in 12 participants (8%) indicated they had not tried to address unpaid wages for fear their employer would speak badly of them.

Numerous participants indicated they would not take action because their employer had power to undermine the migrant’s future job prospects by giving a poor reference or tarnishing the migrant’s reputation in their industry.

I don't want my reputation in this industry or my job prospects in the future to be affected by my employer.
29-year-old female international student from Singapore in TAS
We don't do anything because they bully us into giving bad references that won't allow us next jobs
35-year-old female international student from Bangladesh on a student visa in SA

Some participants noted the particular vulnerability of working in a small town. For example, a 32-year-old Colombian woman who worked in fast food in outer-regional Queensland, for a flat rate that was $9 under the minimum, in cash with no payslips summed up the problem: “small town, big hell”. She indicated that she had not tried, and would not try, to recover unpaid wages because she feared the employer would speak badly of her, and everyone else puts up with it.

Some concerns about the employer’s control over the migrant’s reputation likely reflect situations in which the migrant and their employer were from the same community. These concerns are particularly acute for those with poorer English language skills who are more reliant on community contacts to find a job.

Unless u can provide a job, I think most people would not ask for legal help, they don't know English well, there are not too many jobs available in Sydney, and most positions are introduced by friends by brokers like through interpersonal relationships. If the employees sue or make trouble for their employers, they are gonna fall into a situation like social death..... Every employer in that area may know this person. Social death means no job opportunities, no money, all efforts are in vain, I think most Australian people don't understand what costs for those temporary visa holders
24-year-old male international student from China who worked as a waiter in cash without payslips in NSW

One in seven participants (15%) indicated they would not pursue unpaid wages because they did not want to make trouble for their employer. This may reflect a sense of loyalty to the employer and gratitude for the job, or may reflect similar concerns to those raised above in relation to employers from the same community who are able to damage the migrant’s reputation and future job prospects.

Employer may retaliate against the migrant’s co-workers

A smaller cohort (6%) indicated that they feared problems for their co-workers if they took action, though this is likely an under-reporting of this factor as some participants (and their co-workers) would no longer have been in the relevant job at the time of the survey and this would not be a concern in relation to taking action in the future.

Getting first job in aus are hard obviously. So people get their friends to help them find a job through their connections. So when it's through someone's connections that you get a job and that employer is taking advantage of you, you can't really do anything because you don't want to create rifts between them and get them fired or bullied at work.
20-year-old female international student from India who received no payslips had had deductions for mistakes in QLD

Employer may retaliate by harming the migrant or their family

114 participants (4%) indicated that they had not tried, and would not try, to recover unpaid wages because ‘I fear harm to me or my family if I complain’.

Asked me to join the case to get refund on my paid back money to the owner, but I was too scared.
28-year-old male international student from China in QLD
Fear of harming me or my family… i fear my family get hurt
42-year-old international student from Sri Lanka in NSW

In open responses, some participants indicated the fear related to an employer within their community.

Once, I asked my employer why I was hired as a casual worker and only paid $23, and he treated me like a complete idiot. He said that all restaurants and all Sydney stores are run like this, and if you want to find a place that pays more, look for it. He also said that it is presumptuous to ask about the salary before starting work. (I asked because the salary was not listed in the job advertisement.) I wanted to report it to NSW right away, but I couldn't report it because my personal information was already in it because I had already submitted my resume. I still clearly remember him getting angry, and I was so sad and hopeless that I couldn't report it because I was afraid of him and couldn't confidently ask for my rights anywhere. This is the reality. All stores are run like this.
Female international student from South Korea who worked in hospitality and was sometimes paid cash and never given payslips in NSW

Participants also referred to these employers’ ability to harm their family and community in their home country.

Don’t wanna be seen as a trouble maker. Don’t wanna cause problems for friends and coworkers. All these tie to the fact that if people in your community hate you, they can do you a lot of damage in all sorts of ways and not all here in Australia.
28-year-old male refugee from Pakistan who received threats to himself or his family in his construction job in NSW

Union membership reduces migrants’ fears of retaliatory job loss

Among participants who had not taken steps to recover unpaid wages, non-union members were more likely to attribute this to fear of losing their job (33%) than union members (28%).

Among all of the possible reasons for not trying to recover unpaid wages, the only barrier selected by substantially more union members than non-union members was that it was too much work to pursue unpaid wages (selected as a barrier by 19% of union members, compared with 14% of non-union members).

Barrier 2 · Migration settings

Speaking up can jeopardise the migrant’s current visa and/or immigration pathway

Aside from the fear of losing their work, the next most significant barrier that impeded migrants from trying to address underpayment was fear they would jeopardise their current visa status and/or their future immigration pathway. This was selected by 28% of participants.

Many participants feared that raising an issue with their employer, contacting the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) or initiating a wage claim could lead to cancellation of their current visa or adversely affect eligibility for future visas including pathways to permanent residence. This concern was common across visa categories, but manifested in different ways based on the specific visa settings.

Bad things happen a lot for international people. But most of us don't want to make problem because of the visa.
27-year-old female Working Holiday visa holder from South Korea in SA

International students – Fear of discovery of breach of work hours limitation and generalised visa cancellation fears

Among 2,749 current international students who knew they had been underpaid but had not tried to recover unpaid wages, 28% indicated that this was due to not wanting ‘problems with my visa’.

At the start of the job I ask for a proper job that obeys the policies as well as my visa conditions. However, I was denied. I continues to work as I do wish for experience that I could use for a better job in the future. From time to time I want to report this problem to Fairwork but afraid that it might affect my own visa.
18-year-old Cambodian male international student paid $17 per hour flat rate on nights and weekends, in cash, with deductions for uniforms, who was made to work long hours and was sexually harassed in VIC

Numerous students connected their visa fears with a lack of knowledge about their rights and concerns that taking any action may jeopardise their visa.

It's very exhausting. It's very disheartening. We feel alone, especially as students. Constantly feeling the threat of being harmed or affecting our visa because many of us are literally not even 20 and in our late teens. Away from family and not aware of our rights.
22-year-old female international student from India paid $16/hr in cash with no payslip as a waitress in NSW

This was combined with a sense that they were alone with the problem and did not have access to information and help.

They should set up a help center for international students where they give us all this information and we can ask questions. Many students are unaware of their rights and for fear of losing their visa they remain silent.
33-year-old female university student from Honduras in NSW
I think students are always worried about their visa conditions and that's why scared to complain about anything at their job. This is where you should work on. We should have some support or some place where we can go and talk about our issues.
30-year-old male international student from Bangladesh in VIC

Specific fear that breach of 48-hour work limitation condition could be detected

Many international students indicated they would not address underpayment or other exploitation because they were afraid that this would lead to detection of work in excess of the 48-hour work limit on their visa. Breaching the work limitation appears to have an overwhelming silencing effect on international students, regardless of the severity of exploitation they experience in the workplace.

How migration settings establish employer power over international students

ReadHide

Under Condition 8105 of the student visa,34 international students are only permitted to work up to 48 hours per fortnight while their course is in session. Breach of Condition 8105 gives rise to discretionary power to cancel a student visa under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).35 In reality, very few visas are cancelled for breach of this condition. Between 2020 and 2022 no student visas were cancelled for breach of this condition.36 Nevertheless, the discretion to cancel remains and has been used in the past,37 so the fear is rational.

In July 2024 (the same month the survey was conducted), the Government launched the Strengthening Reporting Protections (SRP) pilot.38 The SRP is intended to enable international students to obtain a guarantee that the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) will not cancel their visa if they have breached a work-related visa condition, or a discretionary assurance against visa cancellation for breach of a non-work condition, if there is a link between that visa breach and a workplace exploitation matter.39 The student must also show that the government or an Accredited Third Party (ATP) is helping the student to resolve the workplace matter, and there is no other reason to cancel the visa.40

In practice, the SRP has not provided students with adequate protection to come forward. The government has limited access to the pilot to a small number of students by authorising only a very small number of ATPs to certify an SRP application.41 Among the few applications lodged for protection against visa cancellation, DHA has not provided formal decisions - meaning that students do not, in effect, receive the tangible assurance the SRP was designed to provide.

In addition, even if protection is obtained and the student’s visa is not cancelled, detection of breach of condition 8105 can have other immigration consequences. For example, work experience cannot be counted for a points tested visa where the work was done in breach of a visa condition and there may be difficulties relying on that experience when seeking formal assessment of skills.42

48-hour fortnightly work limitation may constrain access to decent work

As discussed in the previous section, numerous factors constrain international students’ access to lawfully paid jobs, including lack of local experience and connections in the Australian labour market. Many students indicated that the 48-hour per fortnight work limitation creates a further barrier to employability as they do not have flexibility to increase their working hours as needed by the employer. They noted that employers were not willing to consider hiring them for lawful jobs because of the cap on their working hours. As a result, the only jobs available were underpaid and exploitative. This in turn resulted in them working more hours than permitted to address wage shortfalls.

It is very difficult to get work as a student as we have work hour restrictions, therefore, we have to do whatever work we get. This is the main reason immigrant workers won't complain even if they are mistreated or paid less than what they deserve.
Female international student from Bhutan in WA
As a student and the limitations we have to work, we often accept and let the employer take advantage of our needs and we prefer not to do or say anything.
37-year-old female international student from Ecuador in QLD

A 33-year-old female Pakistani student in NSW reported being made to pay back wages in cash, sexual harassment and pay of $10 per hour in her lowest paid job in 2023-24, with deductions for mistakes. Noting she needed to work to pay off debt, she explained that her situation was part of a broader pattern of exploitation grounded in students’ visa fears:

Limited restricted working hours opens up a window for greedy employers to exploit students who are young and naive new to this country. They use them offer them cash wages due to debts or other reasons they end up agreeing to these scammers. They are scared to lose their visas as well and are constantly being harassed, threatened and exploited.
33-year-old female international student from Pakistan in NSW

Underpaid students work additional hours to make up the wage shortfall, leading to breach of 48-hour work limitation

Many international students noted that because of the unlawfully low wages they were being paid, they had to work many more hours to make up the shortfall, in many cases exceeding the number of hours permitted under their visa. This creates a vulnerability to visa cancellation if detected, which in turn makes students more susceptible to exploitation because they cannot risk reporting their conditions.

I think when people first arrive and are looking for the first job so they can have experience they are taken advantage of. I was paid 17 dollars per hour in cash including Sundays and public holidays. I had to work more than 40 hours per fortnightly to get enough money and then I was scared of being reported to immigration because it exceed the amount of hours a student could work.
35-year-old female international student from Brazil in QLD
I and many people I know were working cash-in-hand because of the hours limitation of the student visa; this situation led to threats from employers of contacting immigration if we complain as we were working more than we were allowed, but if we don't have family support is very hard to live and study in Australia working only 20 hours/week. It feels like the system is design in a way that facilitates the exploitation of people on student visas; everyone knows what is going on but no real change is made to support us.
36-year-old woman from Brazil paid flat rate of $15 per hour on nights and weekends in hospitality in TAS
Migration settings silence underpaid international students, increasing their vulnerability to exploitation
The international student exploitation cycle Need income for cost of living Difficulty obtaining lawfully paid jobs 48-hour visa work restriction Lack of local contacts and experience Insecure job with wages far below legal minimum Work more hours to make up the wage shortfall Breach the 48-hour work restriction on their visa Vulnerable to visa cancellation Too risky and hard to report exploitation Employer exploits their vulnerability and unwillingness to report No external visibility or enforcement

Underpaid wages push international students over their 48-hour fortnightly work limit to make ends meet. Fear of losing their visa then stops them from reporting the employer who underpays them, making them more vulnerable to exploitation.

Students misperceive ways their visa may be cancelled

Numerous students indicated that they remained silent for fear that their employer would cancel their visa. Some mistakenly believed that the employer could in fact cancel the visa, while others feared the employer would report the student to Immigration. For some, this threat was implicit. For others, it was made explicit by the employer. Under new laws introduced in 2024, it is now a crime for an employer to use a threat of immigration reporting to coerce a migrant to accept certain work arrangements.43

I am scared that this data might be shared with this previous employer. Please don't do it, he can cancel my visa.
21-year-old female international student from Sri Lanka who was paid $18 per hour at a car wash in her lowest paid job in 2023-24 in NSW

Students also expressed fear of visa precariousness that extended to a range of issues that are not in fact a basis for visa cancellation, such as accepting wages in cash.

I thought my visa would be cancelled when I accepted the cash job so I was afraid to complain. I then lodged a complain on fair work anonymously but nothing happened. The cafe is still in operation even though they are known to underpay workers and commit multiple violations. I felt like no one cares about temporary visa holders.
30-year-old female international student from Taiwan in NSW

A previous survey conducted by Berg and Farbenblum found that 82% of international students wrongly believed that their student visa could be cancelled for failure to pay rent or other tenancy breaches.44

Working holiday visa holders – Fear of jeopardising completion of 88-day regional work requirement for second year visa

Immigration concerns were cited by around one in five current Working Holiday (417) and Work and Holiday (462) visa holders who knew they were underpaid and had not sought to recover wages owed (18% of 74 participants). (Given a large number of Working visa holders had arrived before 2022, we also considered the 102 underpaid working holiday visa holders who answered this question, finding that one in four (25%) cited visa concerns (25 participants).)

How migration settings establish employer power over Working Holiday visa holders

ReadHide

Working Holiday and Work and Holiday visa holders may apply for a second-year visa upon completion of 88 days of work in horticulture or other specified industries in regional Australia.45 Second year visa holders may apply for a third year after completion of 6 months of eligible work. Because the visa applicant needs to provide DHA with evidence of 88 days of eligible work (for instance an employment contract and pay slips), losing the job could result in being rendered ineligible for the second year and losing permission to stay in Australia upon the expiry of their first visa. This concern is especially acute for migrants towards the end of their visa who may not have alternate opportunities to complete the 88 days.

Participants directly connected the 88-day work requirement with their decision to not take action to address unpaid wages and exploitation. Among the 14 current Working Holiday underpaid visa holders who worked on a farm in their lowest paid job in 2023-24, 43% indicated they would not try to recover unpaid wages because they don’t want problems with their visa.

My friend was working in a farm contracted as a causal but paid under legal,he got no option because he need second year visa.So sad to hear about this
32-year-old female international student from Hong Kong in WA

A 25-year-old Malaysian female Work and Holiday visa holder who was paid $4 per hour on a farm in outer-regional in NSW explained:

We here don't have a choice because our visas (me and on behalf of all my friends that I met here because we talked about this issue everyday) require us to do farm jobs for visa extension. And we are staying in remote areas, we can't leave the job unless we have secured another job. Otherwise, we can only stay despite being unpaid and unable to pay rent and our life expenses.

Employer-sponsored skilled visa holders – Fear of losing visa and immigration pathway that depend on employer sponsorship

Skilled visa holders were most likely to cite visa concerns as a barrier to recovering their wages. Out of 13 underpaid employer-sponsored skilled visa holders who arrived in Australia from 2022, more than half (7; 54%) cited this reason for not pursuing unpaid wages. (Given that most skilled visa holders had arrived before 2022, we also considered the 46 underpaid employer-sponsored skilled visa holders who answered this question, finding that over one in three (37%) cited visa concerns (17 participants).) For those who did not cite this as a reason, it is possible that they were underpaid by a previous employer (either a different sponsor or on a different previous visa), so fear of losing that job was no longer relevant.

Employers wield extreme power over sponsored migrants. If the migrant loses an employer-sponsored job they may lose their visa and/or pathway to permanent residence. Many sponsored migrants indicated they could not speak up in the face of serious exploitation because of their employer’s influence over their future in Australia.

My employer was the sponsor on my visa which even though I paid myself to come to Australia, it gave them the power ... it was impossible to reach [their] targets without working a lot of unpaid overtime.
41-year-old female sponsored healthcare worker from South Africa in NSW

How migration settings establish employer power over migrants on different skilled sponsored visas

ReadHide
Skills in Demand (482) visa and Skilled Employer Sponsored Regional (494) visa

The main employer-sponsored temporary work visa is the Skills in Demand (subclass 482) visa, which is subject to work limitation condition 8607.46 Under this condition, the visa holder may only work for their sponsor in their nominated occupation unless they qualify for an exemption. Up until the time of the survey (July 2024), visa holders who were no longer employed by their sponsor had 60 days to find a new sponsoring employer.47 Under the July 2024 reforms, visa holders may cease employment with their sponsor for up to 180 consecutive days, and 365 cumulative days in total (during this 180-day period, the visa holder may work for any employer (or themself) and in any occupation). Detection of breach of condition 8607 (e.g. ceasing to be employed by sponsor for more than 180 consecutive days) is a ground for discretionary visa cancellation (subject to obtaining SRP protection).48

A 482 visa holder may change sponsors but a new nomination by the new sponsor is required, and the visa holder must already be approved to work in the nominated occupation for the new sponsor.49 If the visa holder wants to change occupation, they must lodge a new visa application.50 In other words, to remain on their current visa they have 180 days to secure another employer who is eligible and willing to sponsor them in the same occupation.

A similar condition applies to the Skilled Employer Sponsored Regional 494 visa.51 However this visa also carries the further restriction that the migrant must remain in regional Australia for the duration of the 5-year visa.52

Labour agreements

Labour agreements are individual arrangements between employers and the Department of Home Affairs which enable approved businesses to sponsor overseas workers outside of standard temporary or permanent visa programs, and provide concessions relating to the standard eligibility criteria of visas such as the 482 (for example, in relation to the base salary, work experience or English language requirements).53 Employers in certain industries (such as aged care or horticulture) may access labour agreements based on general terms that have been agreed in advance by DHA on an industry-wide basis. Alternatively, employers in certain rural and regional areas may access labour agreements based on terms agreed by the Department in concluding Designated Area Migration Agreements (DAMA), often, with concessions such as lower English language ability or lower salary requirements.54

Condition 8607 also applies to 482 visa holders who are employed under the Labour Agreement stream.55 For these workers, however, there are further restrictions on changing jobs and/or employers.56 The new employer must hire the worker under an approved Labour Agreement covering the relevant occupation and the new employer must lodge a new nomination for the worker.57 A worker cannot simply transfer to an employer in the standard business sponsorship stream of 482 or to a different Labour Agreement that does not cover the worker’s occupation or circumstances.58

Employer sponsorship for permanent residence (186 visa)

The Employer Nomination Scheme (subclass 186) visa allows Australian employers to nominate skilled foreign workers for permanent residence to fill vacancies in their businesses.59 Workers may be sponsored directly for permanent residency (through the ‘direct entry’ stream) or through prior work for the employer as 482 visa holders (through the ‘temporary residence transition’ stream). Unlike the regional equivalent of this permanent visa (subclass 191) that allows the migrant to self-sponsor for permanent residence upon accruing relevant work in Australia, the 186 visa requires an employer to nominate the job and sponsor the applicant – even if they have completed the requisite period of work for the employer as a temporary visa-holder.60

I was bullied by my superiors at work but could not resign because that means giving up my visa and losing PR status. It led to me experiencing depression for a year because of this. I also found out that my starting pay and speed of going up salary levels was less than some male peers in my team.
38-year-old woman from Malaysia who held an employer-sponsored visa in VIC

This may be done as early as 2 years into a provisional visa.61 As a result, a migrant may remain with a sponsoring employer for an extended period in reliance on an early promise of imminent sponsorship.

Ive been eligible for Permanent Residence since November last year but my employer has been ignoring my requests to start the process. I have heard from managers that the reason is that he knows I’m unhappy, and he knows I’m basically trapped, so he wants to lock me to the company as long as possible.
32-year-old male skilled professional worker from South Africa in QLD

Occupation restrictions in skilled visas drive employer dependence, especially in regional Australia and even more so under labour agreements

Although 482 visa holders now have 180 days to find a new sponsoring employer, this remains a challenging proposition for many migrants. It carries a high degree of risk and uncertainty for migrants who often do not have local labour market knowledge and connections. The risk of not finding another sponsor in the same occupation is even higher for those whose visas confine them to regional Australia, where jobs in the specific occupation may be far more limited. For workers sponsored under a DAMA, the prospect of finding a new sponsor in the same occupation who is already approved under a DAMA becomes even more speculative. In some occupations in particular regions, there may be only one or two companies that could offer eligible roles under a DAMA so the opportunity to change employers is illusory in practice.

[I did not raise problems at work] because I thought I was not going to find another sponsor job in 494 visa, because we could work only for sponsor in regional Australia and period time was 3 months to find a new sponsor and I would have to leave Australia. Now, there is 6 months to find a new sponsor, but I have been looking for job for 2 months and I haven’t found office manager job yet because my visa is DAMA.
34-year-old woman from Peru subjected to ongoing bullying and abuse on an employer-sponsored 494 regional visa under a DAMA in very remote WA

The level of risk and difficulty of attempting to change sponsors leads many to continue in exploitative jobs without raising a concern in order to securely maintain their immigration pathway. An employer-sponsored chef in Queensland described the impact of this level of control:

Was forced to do questionable things for a person in power who had full control over my migration status
Male 491-visa holder from Paraguay

Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) visa holders - Fear of losing visa, stay, and return to Australia that are dependent on a single employer

Pacific Islander workers on the PALM Scheme are even more dependent on their employers because these workers are not able to freely change employers.

How migration settings establish employer power over migrants on the PALM Scheme

ReadHide

Condition 8611 on a PALM (subclass 403) visa requires that the visa holder only work for an Authorised Employer approved by the Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (DEWR).62 Condition 8516 requires the visa holder to continue to satisfy visa criteria, including remaining employed by their Authorised Employer.63 Breach of either condition can lead to visa cancellation and removal.64

PALM Scheme workers in the short-term visa stream are also reliant on their employer in order to return to Australia because sponsorship by an Approved Employer is also required for a future visa application. In principle, a PALM Scheme worker could find an alternative Approved Employer to sponsor them but in reality, reengagement in the scheme is generally through a previous sponsor (who typically maintains a relationship with the hiring government agency in a sending country) and any alternative would be highly speculative.

A very small number of PALM visa holders participated in the survey. Recognising that the survey would have been inaccessible to migrants on the PALM Scheme due to language, literacy and cultural barriers, we conducted a separate survey of 370 PALM workers in 2024, examining the specific barriers to accessing justice for underpayment and other workplace breaches for this cohort (see box below for key findings).65

One PALM Scheme participant in the main survey conveyed the leverage that employers have to exploit workers on the scheme, flowing from the power of sponsorship.

They did not pay well, took double deductions for our visa and flights. We were not sleeping well because we were so crowded and there was no privacy. Our overtime was not paid. They provided different payslips than what was supposed to be on them. We were threatened for all our mistakes that we would be sent back to PNG.
28-year-old male farm worker in remote NSW in the PALM scheme

Across visa categories, employers keep exploited migrants silent through a promise of future sponsorship for a temporary or permanent visa

Numerous participants recounted their employers’ use of a promise of sponsorship to keep them silent under exploitative conditions, sometimes for months or years. This is a common powerful driver of exploitation that is especially difficult to address. It is hard to prove an explicit or implicit promise made verbally, and easy for an employer to dispute the promise was made, or otherwise explain why circumstances had changed and the person was no longer suitable or needed by the company.

I worked for a Petrol Company for 5 years. I had worked overtime and did management duties on the side because the manager at that time wanted to ‘train’ me (no payment or extra work compensation). I worked tirelessly for free and I was also overworked in an understaffed workplace. With the extra work, i asked them if i could be Sponsored by the company in the future. They mentioned they would happily support me. When i was on my 485 Temp Grad visa, i ended up being a manager in that company. When the time came for me to cash that request in, after making me wait for 8 months, they refused and denied me the visa. When I asked them the reason, they denied saying it was something they stopped doing. I went on to talk and ask people around the company and someone mentioned that they got sponsorship with the same company on that day. I felt very bad for myself as I had put a lot of years and time in the company and was given false promises.
27-year-old female international student from India who worked for a flat rate of $25 per hour at all times, was made to pay wages back in cash to the boss, was made to pay for uniform, and was made to work for more than 14 days at a time without a day off in QLD

An Indonesian international student (male, 33) who was significantly underpaid in a nail salon job in VIC in 2023-24 shared:

Two of my employer agreed verbally they want to help sponsored my visa, this practice is making us the migrant who want to really work in Australia work above and beyond for them, but in the end, there were no black and white contract about the conversation, so employer felt no obligation to actually sponsor visa. it should be illegal to talk about sponsorship while no proper regulation and taking advantage from us.

The problem is equally acute with employer sponsorship for permanent residence.

I have to accept everything my employer tells me, I am on a 482 visa and if I say no, he will not nominate me for residency through the 186 trt. It is very hard on the 482 visa for the employer to be the one who nominates the worker. That helps them exploit us and in the end not give us the visa.
34-year-old male from Colombia on 482 visa in WA

Migrants may need to maintain their job to satisfy work experience requirements to apply for a future visa

In addition to reliance on maintaining a job for employer-sponsored migration pathways, some migrants rely on their job for the relevant work experience they require to be eligible for certain visas. For example, for points-tested skilled visas (such as a Skilled Independent (subclass 189) visa), Australian work experience in the nominated occupation or a closely related skilled occupation is especially valuable because it accrues more points than overseas work experience. For work experience to be considered, it must generally be for remuneration, at least 20 hours per week, and in a certain skilled occupation.67

In addition, skills assessments are mandatory for some visa applicants. For some occupations, a mandatory skills assessment and evidence of 12 months’ work experience within the last five years at the appropriate skill level may be required.68 The advice of assessing authorities is generally accepted by DHA for both visa criteria and points test purposes.

I need the job to gain valid employment history for migration points, so I had to work long hours and could not leave office without my boss permission. They know I have to secure the job so they leveraged that to force me to work.
30-year-old female temporary graduate from China who worked in a consulting firm in TAS

Migrants fear that contacting a government authority could jeopardise their visa

Migrant workers’ fear of engaging with government is well documented.69 Among survey participants who knew they were underpaid, only 3% contacted the FWO, although 59% had been aware of the existence of the FWO. Migrants expressed a fear that immigration consequences could flow once the government’s attention has been drawn to the migrant’s situation. Migrants’ perception of government as a single entity is not irrational given that there is no firewall preventing FWO from passing on the worker’s information to DHA.70 In fact, in the context of monitoring employer sponsor arrangements, and in the context of joint enforcement initiatives, the FWO is generally required to share information with DHA.71 This can make contact with the FWO a high-risk prospect for migrant workers who may have breached their visa.

At the time of the survey, an Assurance Protocol was in place between the FWO and DHA, under which the FWO can provide the worker’s details to DHA and DHA ‘generally’ will not cancel a temporary visa if the holder has breached work-related visa conditions as a direct result of being exploited at work.72 Reflecting the lack of trust in the discretionary visa non-cancellation practice under the Assurance Protocol, only around 15 migrants have been referred under the Protocol per year since its introduction in 2017.73

As noted before, the Strengthening Reporting Protections Pilot (SRP) and Workplace Justice Visa Pilot (WJV) commenced the same month as the survey (July 2024).74 These have the potential to overcome migrants’ immigration fears associated with contacting the FWO. However, as discussed earlier, the government has deliberately restricted access to the SRP and WJV for most migrant workers.

People always said that we can go to Fair Work to get justice for our terrible employers, but I never trusted that I would not face ramifications regarding my visa if I did so.
30-year-old female international student from the United States in VIC

Fear of detection by the Australian Border Force (ABF) is even more extreme for undocumented workers - migrants who have overstayed a visa or are working while holding a visa that prohibits work - who are also most vulnerable to exploitation. These workers are not eligible for the Workplace Justice Visa. If they are detected by ABF, they may be detained and removed from Australia with no opportunity to remain in the country to pursue a claim for unpaid wages or any other workplace breaches.75 Once apprehended, there is no routine referral from ABF to Fair Work Inspectors or labour compliance. Thus, although the Government passed legislation in 2023 confirming that undocumented workers are protected by the Fair Work Act regardless of immigration status,76 it is almost impossible for these workers to enforce their rights and recover unpaid wages without triggering their removal.

Barrier 3 · Knowledge

Migrants lack critical information about workplace rights and require assistance to enforce rights

One in four migrants do not address underpayment because they do not know what to do or how to access help

The third most common barrier that impeded underpaid participants from trying to recover unpaid wages was that they did not know ‘where to go or what to do’. This reason was selected by 24% of participants, including a slightly higher proportion of women (25%) than men (22%).

I worked in a restaurant... At first they provided me 15$/h with a promise to increase the rate in the future. Which they didn't. They paid me in cash. Later they [did not pay] my 67 hours payment which is equivalent to 1000$. I failed to retrieve the money as I don't know what to do. Then left the job hopelessly.
26-year-old female international student from India who worked in hospitality in NSW

Some participants articulated a strong need for assistance and support to navigate their employment rights and wage recovery.

It's been really hard to manage everything on my own with no one to guide or be by my side. I just don't know what to do
22-year-old female international student from India who earned $18/hr at a fast food restaurant on an ABN in NSW

Several participants shared in open responses that they were unsure how to access assistance for specific forms of noncompliance. These included an employer not providing requisite break periods, misclassification of an employee as an Independent Contractor on an ABN, failure to pay the casual loading, non-payment of superannuation, an unpaid trial, racism and bullying.

I recently checked my super fund and saw there is only $600 in there. In contrast my payslips state that they have contributed close to $4,000. Unfortunately I am not sure exactly where to go to fix this.
31-year-old man from the US on a bridging visa in QLD

Migrants generally know the National Minimum Wage but lack information about other key workplace rights

Two in three migrants do not know the minimum wage for casual employees

In a separate part of the survey, we asked participants what they thought was the minimum wage, and minimum wage for casual employees, in Australia at the time of the survey (after responding, participants were then provided with the correct answers). Over three quarters of respondents (77%) knew that the National Minimum Wage was $23 or more.77

In contrast, only one in three respondents (32%) could correctly identify that the minimum wage for casual employees was $29 or more.78 Even among participants who worked as casual employees in their lowest paid job in 2023-24, only 34% could correctly identify the minimum wage with a casual loading.

This suggests around two thirds of casual employees would not have known the extent of unpaid wages owing to them, and some may have decided to not pursue unpaid wages on this basis.

Two in five migrants do not know that temporary visa holders are entitled to Australian minimum wages

About one fifth (18%) of 8,802 survey participants wrongly believed that temporary migrants are not entitled to the same minimum wage as Australian workers and a further 23% were unsure. This suggests that over 40% of participants may have been unsure about whether their underpayment was in fact lawful, which may have influenced their decision to not pursue unpaid wages.

Migrants lack information about other key workplace rights and responsibilities

Participants wrote detailed open responses about their acute need for information and assistance in a range of areas of employment law. These included the employee’s obligation to pay tax (participants were unsure how to acquire a Tax File Number and the implications of income tax withholding), an employee’s entitlement to superannuation, paid and unpaid leave, minimum hours of a casual shift, youth wage rates, and misclassification of an employee as an Independent Contractor on an ABN. Many reported that they struggled to determine their entitlements given the complexity of award levels and especially when they received no records of their employment.

I did not know about yearly increase of minimum wage, did not have a written contract, did not receive weekly payslip, hence did not know my exact job title
34-year-old woman from South Korea working in hospitality in TAS

Some participants observed that their knowledge of labour rights was particularly poor when they first arrived and improved over time and with experience in the Australian labour market.

This happened more than 5 years ago when I first came to Australia and I didn't know about the law and also know my value.
23-year-old woman from Vietnam on a student visa who worked in a nail salon at $10/hr with no payslips in VIC

Several referred to the need for more detailed information, both on arrival and again at the point in time that they needed it.

It would be great to know these conditions and rights from the beginning if you had ambassadors, contacts, someone in Spanish who could explain this to you from the beginning when you arrive in Australia (perhaps alliances with study agencies to know this from the beginning).
36-year-old female international student from Colombia in VIC
It would be great if the information I have learnt from this survey becomes more accessible (maybe compulsorily included in the hiring process) to more workers on temporary visas like me. Knowledge about tax and superannuation should also be discussed.
25-year-old female international student from Vietnam who worked as a barista with no payslips and deductions for mistakes and poor performance in SA

Finally, participants expressed their lack of awareness about whether they were entitled to bring a claim at all, particularly for ‘cash jobs’.

I decided to take legal action, I was unsure if I could file a case against him as an international student, as it was a cash job even though I worked on my semester break. But luckily, I got to fill this survey and now I am clear that I can take legal actions against him. Thank you so much for this information!
22-year-old female international student from Nepal in NSW

Most migrants mistakenly believe that exploited migrants are complicit in breaking the law and this deters reporting

In a separate part of the survey, we asked participants questions based on common misconceptions that may influence their decision to accept or stay in an underpaid job, and to not report exploitative conditions in that job.79

Most temporary migrants mistakenly believe that receiving cash wages is, or may be, unlawful, with some perceiving this could lead to visa cancellation

Around three fifths of 8,334 respondents wrongly believed that if they accept cash wages they would (38%) or may (21%) be breaking the law. While payment of wages in cash may be used to avoid complying with legal obligations, it is not unlawful to pay or receive wages in cash.

Three in five workers believed a person has, or might have, broken the law if they agreed to be paid wages in cash

Figure 5. Answers to the question ‘Is a worker breaking the law if they agree to be paid wages in cash?’, excluding permanent residents, citizens and skilled visa holders (n=8,334)

The fear of having broken the law by accepting cash is a powerful disincentive to approaching the FWO or other government departments.

Most cash-paying workers think that they have also committed an illegal act, so no one reports it.
Female international student from South Korea who worked in hospitality and was paid in cash and did not receive payslips in NSW
I know many students who are having a bad time at their part-time or casual jobs. Many shy off from complaining as they are scared to talk to fair workers or govt officials. I am pretty sure many students are working and getting paid in cash and are not treated equally because they cannot complaint to the officials because they are also in the wrong.
26-year-old male international student from India in VIC

Numerous participants indicated that they believed that discovery of their acceptance of cash wages could lead to cancellation of their visa.

I thought my visa would be cancelled when I accepted the cash job so I was afraid to complain.
30-year-old female international student from Taiwan in NSW
there are many students working on cash which is illegal so they don’t try to recover as if they do, employers can complain immigration about them and they would be in trouble.
28-year-old female international student from Pakistan in NSW

Most migrants mistakenly believe that it is or may be unlawful for a worker to ‘agree’ to underpaid wages

Almost half (45%) of 8,341 survey participants wrongly believed that ‘a worker is breaking the law if they agree to be paid less than the minimum wage’. A further 31% were unsure. Fewer than one in four knew that it is not unlawful for a worker to acquiesce to underpayment.

It follows that a migrant who believes they have, or may have, broken the law would be reluctant to bring this to light by seeking to recover unpaid wages, especially in light of pervasive concerns for visa status and immigration pathways. A Chinese international student in Queensland (28-years-old) noted she would not pursue unpaid wages because ‘we [migrant and employer] both agree with I was paid less and in cash’.

Three quarters of participants believed a person has, or might have, broken the law if they agreed to be paid below the minimum wage

Figure 6. Answer to the question ‘Is a worker breaking the law if they agreed to be paid less than the minimum wage?’, excluding permanent residents, citizens and skilled visa holders (n=8,341).

In the question on reasons why participants had not, and would not try to recover unpaid wages, one in five participants (19%) indicated they did not try to recover unpaid wages because ‘I agreed to the wage so I have no complaint’. Some may have felt they did not have a moral right to complain about a wage rate they agreed to at the outset. However, a substantial portion were likely under the mistaken belief that they gave up their legal right to statutory minimum wages when they reached an agreement for a lower wage rate.

Migrants have difficulty engaging with information provided by the Fair Work Ombudsman

As discussed in Part 6, over a third of participants (37%) were not aware of the existence of the national labour regulator, the FWO. Other participants reported that they attempted to seek information via the FWO website but were unable to understand the information and apply it to their circumstances.

The Fair Work Ombudsman, while I'm sure it is helpful and has the information I need, is extremely complicated and hard to follow when I am trying to digest all of the work information starting from nothing. Thus, I do not know all of my rights and am disinclined to look at the website for this information, making me unsure where to go.
21-year-old non-binary student from the US in NSW
it is quite difficult to find information regarding work legislation. I have had a challenging time navigating the Fair Work website, as it is not easy or clear to access the necessary information.
32-year-old male international student from Italy in QLD

Some migrants perceive their English proficiency as an impediment to addressing underpayment

Overall, 13% selected ‘My English isn’t good enough’ as a reason for not having taken steps to recover unpaid wages. This is likely an underestimate as the survey was only offered in five languages other than English and may have been inaccessible to other participants with poor English language proficiency. Indeed, among 445 Chinese participants who undertook the survey in Mandarin, 33% selected this as a reason why they would not seek to recover unpaid wages. Among 121 Colombian participants who took the survey in Spanish, 24% selected this as a reason.

However, only 16% of those who indicated they ‘did not know where to go or what to do’ also selected ‘My English isn’t good enough’ as a reason for not having tried to recover unpaid wages. This suggests that participants’ lack of knowledge about where to access support was not primarily driven by inadequate language skills.

Barrier 4 · Process

Too complicated and ultimately unlikely to deliver unpaid wages

Migrants perceive the complexity and time required to recover wages as prohibitive

Many participants described the challenges of navigating complex processes.

The person from the government agency was very helpful but the process to report the problem was complicated and it didn't feel worth it
37-year-old woman from France on a partner visa in QLD

This was especially the case for those considering the investment of time and effort a wage claim would require while juggling the demands of underpaid and difficult work, often at night and on weekends, alongside life demands and studies.

Many participants noted that navigating any processes was too difficult for a migrant without help.

It's hard to get help, the process is too cumbersome, and I don't have time to waste on this.
Temporary graduate from China, 37-year-old male, who experienced threats of harm and being reported to immigration or police in TAS

Migrants believe that even if they try to recover wages they would not be successful, especially with lack of evidence

Around one in seven (14%) indicated they had not, and would not try to recover their unpaid wages because ‘I wouldn’t be successful’. Many pointed to their lack of evidence, particularly when paid in cash. In Off the Books we found almost a quarter (23%) of all migrant workers received some or all of their wages in cash, and almost a quarter (24%) of all migrant employees received no payslips or misleading payslips in their lowest paid job in 2023-24.80

Those who received payslips omitting hours or no payslips at all in their lowest paid job were twice as likely to select this reason than those who consistently received payslips that recorded all their hours (20% vs 11%).

If my employer never gave me payslip, how can i prove that i ever worked there?Does text messages with the employer sufficient to do so?
31-year-old male working holiday maker from Indonesia,who worked in fast food in regional Qld

Many participants also noted concerns about proving underpayment when they were paid in cash.

I was trying to keep some evidence of the illegal payment. But when I get paid, I was paid by cash in an envelop. I have no evidence that I get illegal payment.
26-year-old woman from China, on a student visa in NSW

Participants expressed uncertainty about how to evidence underpayment in the context of other non-compliance.

My current job is a bit like casual, but the salary is based on the minimum wage of part-time. I don't want to be specific because I don't know what evidence to provide. I don't know what kind of evidence is legal and useful. At the same time, I am also worried that I will lose this only job.
24-year-old female international student from China in VIC

Migrants perceive that even if claim is successful, employer will not pay

Around one in eight participants (12%) perceived that ‘Even if I win my employer won’t pay’.

Employers liquidate and migrants are excluded from the Fair Entitlements Guarantee

A number of participants noted that their employer went into liquidation. Unlike their Australian citizen co-workers, they were unable to recover any of the outstanding wages they were owed because temporary visa holders are ineligible for the Fair Entitlements Guarantee that covers wages under these circumstances.81

…this company went into Administration and i wasn’t paid super and my salary, in total $8400, rest all the employees got their entitlements back by FEG but i wasn’t as I am not Australian citizen and not covered under FEG… We all worked for same time but they got all their money but I didn’t.
27-year-old male international student from India in NSW
…many of my old employers knew of that loophole and accrued a lot of debt before claiming bankruptcy basically screwing over a lot of their migrant workers who can not access a form of compensation.
24-year-old female international student from France in the ACT
I worked for a company that owed me 2 weeks of wages when they shut down without notice (bankruptcy). If I was an Australian, I would have received those wages through a government program but because I am an international student I didn’t receive anything.
31-year-old female international student from Canada in SA

Employers obstruct migrant wage claims and/or disappear

Numerous participants expressed a sense of resignation that in the same way that their employers were able to disregard their Fair Work Act obligations, it would be easy for their employers to evade liability and obstruct any claims by the migrant.

Indeed, the perception that ‘Even if I win my employer won’t pay’ was especially acute among those whose employers engaged in particularly egregious non-compliance, or worked in insecure jobs, in the participant’s lowest paid job in 2023-24.

For example, participants whose employer made deductions from their pay in their lowest paid job were over 1.5 times as likely to select this response, compared with those whose employer did not make pay deductions (18% vs 11%).

Similarly, those who never received a payslip or received incorrect payslips were almost twice as likely to select this response compared with those who received payslips reflecting the correct hours they worked (17% vs 9%).

Those in insecure jobs (on an ABN and casual employment) were twice as likely to select this barrier compared with permanent employees (14% for ABN workers and casual employees, and 7% of permanent employees).

Some participants noted the power disparity between the migrant and the employer, and the employer’s ability to manipulate the system.

I dont have the funds for a lawyer and dont have energy to go through complex legal processes… They would have the finances for good lawyers and they probably have set things up so this doesnt become an issue.
41-year-old female healthcare skilled worker from South Africa in NSW

Other participants recounted employers’ ability to disappear or evade liability by withholding their official business details required for a claim. This is especially a challenge for the many migrants who are not given a contract or payslips and have no way of identifying the business or locating its owners if they do not want to be found.

At the end of the last week he disappeared and never paid about $3000 worth of work hours. He never answered his phone again… I did not have any other contact details from him, so I lost my money.
36-year-old male 408 visa holder from Colombia in WA
Some employers’ ABNs are not accessible online. The Fair Work needs to ABN to process the complaint… If you cannot get their ABNs, it signifies that you cannot do anything to get your money back from those exploitative employers.
28-year-old male international student from Hong Kong in NSW
Barrier 5 · Peer inaction

Migrants’ expectations of their underpaid labour market and social drivers of remaining silent

As noted above, participants who reported the lowest wage rates in their lowest paid job in 2023-24 were the least likely to try to recover their wages in that job or any other job. This is despite the fact that these participants were owed the greatest sum of unpaid wages per hour.

Their reluctance to take action is partly driven by personal factors that render them vulnerable to working in these egregiously underpaid jobs in the first place. It is also driven by a perception that temporary visa holders comprise a segregated workforce in Australia that lacks access to a compliant labour market. Perceptions of peer inaction, and concerns about how they will be viewed by their community if they take action, also drive migrants’ decision-making in relation to addressing underpayment. These social perception factors are among the hardest to address.

Perception of underpayment as the norm in migrants’ labour market

In a separate part of the survey to the wage recovery questions, 8,864 participants responded to the question: ‘How many people on your visa are paid less than the minimum wage?’. Those in the lowest wage bracket were most likely to perceive that most people on their visa were working in the same egregiously paid jobs. About two thirds of respondents (65%) who earned less than $20 per hour indicated that they believed ‘many’ people on their visa are underpaid (as opposed to ‘some’ or ‘very few’).

Perceived inaction by similarly underpaid peers

One in five (21%) underpaid participants indicated that the reason they had not sought to recover their wages was that ‘Many people around me are being paid similarly and they're not doing anything about it’.

In fact, the lower participants’ wage in their lowest paid job in 2023-24, the more likely they selected ‘Many people around me are paid similarly and they’re not doing anything about it’ as a reason for not trying to recover unpaid wages. Those in the lowest wage bracket, earning less than $20 per hour, were most likely to select their peer group’s inaction as a reason why they had not tried to recover unpaid wages. This suggests these migrants take their cue from their peers who accept this as their labour market and likely infer that it is not appropriate, not possible or not worthwhile to take action.

My co-workers were used to it and didn't worry.
38-years-old female Mongolian international student in VIC

Some participants interpreted their peers’ silence as an indication that speaking up would result in harm to the migrant.

My job is being a waitress at a restaurant near Wollongong CBD. I know there are tons of restaurant owners who underpay their employees. I want to take action against these problems but my fear stops me from doing that. I have to work 4-5 hours a day (including weekend) but my rate is all the same which is $18 per hour. I hardly make ends meet with that rate but my co-workers don't seem to take action so I'm afraid that I will get into trouble when I speak up.
20-year-old female Vietnamese international student in NSW
The lower the migrants’ wages, the more likely their decision to not recover unpaid wages was influenced by their underpaid peers’ inaction

Figure 7. Selection of ‘Many people around me are being paid similarly and they’re not doing anything about it’ as a reason why the participant would not try to recover unpaid wages, by hourly wage bracket.

Notes: Sample is participants who reported knowing they had been underpaid in any job in Australia, who arrived from 2022 onwards and worked in Australia in 2023–24, and had not tried and would not try to recover unpaid wages in relation to any job (n=2,575). Wage brackets are based on participants’ lowest paid job in 2023-24, but attempts to recover wages could relate to any job. Percentages are of participants in each wage bracket. Percentages show the proportion of participants in each wage bracket who selected ‘Many people around me…’ among multiple choice options for the reasons why they would not try to recover unpaid wages.

Participants in insecure jobs were almost twice as likely to select their underpaid peers’ resignation to their circumstances as a reason for their own inaction to recover unpaid wages. This was selected by 22% of those working on an ABN in their lowest paid job in 2023-24 and 25% of those working as a casual employee, compared with 13% of those in permanent employment.

Similar proportions of participants selected this barrier regardless of length of time in Australia (18% of 2024 arrivals, 23% of 2023 arrivals and 20% of 2022 arrivals).

Expectation that migrant jobs will be imperfect

Close to one in five (18%) underpaid participants indicated they did not seek to recover unpaid wages because ‘As migrants we expect our jobs won’t be perfect’.

Our expectations when we first get here is always that we won’t get better jobs and we have been told that we need to be grateful to whatever we find first. I was told by my seniors that i need to be grateful of where I was working as their conditions before was way worse.
29-year-old male Temporary Graduate visa holder from Nepal in VIC

Unlike peer-focused reasons for inaction, this barrier was selected by similar proportions of participants across all levels of underpayment and characteristics of participants’ lowest paid job in 2023-24. It was, however, selected by more men (21%) than women (16%).

As a PhD international student, I often accept minimal wages per hour from our providers/employers because my expectations aren’t high. Simply having a job is considered fortunate… In most cases, I have no choice but to accept that work, and the wages as well.
33-year-old male international student from Indonesia in QLD

Shame and embarrassment

Around one in six participants (16%) indicated that they would not try to recover unpaid wages because ‘I feel embarrassed or worried I might look bad’. For some participants, this reflected a sense of shame in relation to the exploitation itself.

I’m their hostage now working for them and being in AU on bridging visa, so I cant leave them and have no other choice. That’s so embarrassing and humiliating but I cannot do anything cause all my family depends on this.
49-year-old Male bridging visa holder from Greece in VIC

For others, it reflected embarrassment related to speaking up, particularly in relation to the migrant’s community.

I’m not confident enough that if I complain now, it’ll lead to anything or not. I’ll be looked down in my society as well, if it makes news headlines.
24-year-old male international student from Nepal in QLD

Some workers reported their employer deliberately making them feel ashamed when they raised unpaid wages.

…my manager change my time sheet at the end so, he dont pay me overtime. i tried to talk to him but he always make me feel that am greedy for money. i feel like am begging for money.
Male graduate visa holder from Pakistan in WA

Union membership reduced barriers related to social perceptions

Union members appeared more confident to take action and less concerned by embarrassment and peer inaction than participants who had not been a union member. A substantially greater proportion of non-union members indicated they had: not tried to recover unpaid wages because their peers had not taken action (21% of non-union members vs 14% of union members); because as migrants they expected to work in noncompliant jobs (19% vs 14%); or because they would be embarrassed or ashamed (16% vs 10%).

Non-union members were also twice as likely as union members to indicate they had not tried to recover unpaid wages because they agreed to the wage and therefore had no complaint (19% vs 9%) or because they did not want to make trouble for their employer (16% vs 7%).

University of Technology Sydney UNSW Sydney
UTS Law Faculty and UNSW Faculty of Law & Justice are proud supporters of the Migrant Justice Institute. MJI is a charity registered with ACNC. ABN 84654507758.
ACNC Registered Charity
Be the first to know when we publish new research

Get early access to new reports, hear about policy wins first, and stay connected to the fight for migrant worker justice.

Subscribe
Off The Books report cover ‘Right or wrong, just accept it’ report cover
Migrant Workers’ Access to Justice for Wage Theft report cover All Work, No Pay report cover
Migrant Justice Institute

The Migrant Justice Institute respectfully acknowledges the Gadigal and Bedegal peoples of the Eora Nation and the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nations, the traditional owners and custodians of the land on which we work. We pay our respects to their elders past and present and acknowledge that sovereignty was never ceded.

Contents