Response to underpayment
Which migrants took steps to recover unpaid wages
Employers of six in seven underpaid migrants were never held to account for unpaid wages
Survey participants were asked whether they had tried to recover unpaid wages for any job in which they had been underpaid in Australia. They were also given an option to indicate that they did not believe they had been underpaid.
Figure 1. Participants who had tried to recover wages they were owed, among those who reported knowing they had been underpaid in Australia (n=4,835)
The more egregiously migrants are exploited, the less likely they take action
We examined the behavioural responses of those who indicated they were underpaid in any job in Australia, in relation to the wage they reported receiving in their lowest paid job in 2023-24. For every participant, we calculated their approximate dollars per hour underpayment, based on the relevant Award, their entitlement to penalty rates and casual loading, and compared their reported wage with that individual minimum entitlement to calculate hourly underpayment for each participant. (For detailed findings on 8,370 participants’ wages and experiences of working conditions in this lowest paid job see Off the Books: Inside Australia’s Hidden System of Migrant Worker Exploitation.25)
One might assume that the greater the amount a migrant was underpaid, the more likely they would try to recover the unpaid wages. In fact, the opposite was the case: workers who were owed the most in their lowest paid job were the least likely to attempt wage recovery in any job.
Among participants who reported receiving under $20 per hour in their lowest paid job, only 13% had attempted wage recovery in that or any other job in Australia. In contrast, among participants who reported receiving more than the casual minimum of $29 per hour in their lowest paid job in 2023-24, 19% had taken action to recover unpaid wages in that or any other job in Australia. 14% of participants tried to recover their wages among those who received wages between these outer limits in their lowest paid job. This was the case even though the average underpayment for participants who received less than $20 per hour was $15.40 per hour, compared with $3.70 per hour for participants who earned more than the casual minimum wage.
We do not know whether workers who sought to recover wages did so in relation to their lowest paid job or another job. However, it seems that willingness and ability to recover unpaid wages is likely driven at least in part by the worker’s power in the labour market (the quality of jobs they can access). In other words, the same factors driving vulnerability to underpayment also keep underpaid workers silent. Workers who were more underpaid in their lowest paid job may have greater fears of losing any job, and may be less connected to services or networks providing assistance and therefore less likely to take steps to recover their wages in any job.
The much lower rates of wage recovery among workers in the lowest paying jobs may also be driven by aspects of the structure and working conditions in their lowest paid job. In Off the Books we found that workers who received less than $20 per hour were more likely to receive no payslips or misleading payslips, be paid in cash and be engaged as a casual employee (with irregular hours that are more difficult to prove in the absence of payslips) and be engaged unlawfully on an ABN.26 These other areas of non-compliance or job insecurity create additional hurdles to proving underpayment (as we discuss in more detail below).
Figure 2. Underpaid participants who tried to recover unpaid wages, by hourly wage in the lowest paid job in 2023–24.
Notes: Sample is participants who reported knowing they had been underpaid in any job in Australia and who worked in Australia in 2023–24 (n=3,994). Wage brackets are based on each participant’s lowest paid job in 2023–24, but attempts to recover wages could relate to any job. Percentages are of participants in each wage bracket.
Recent arrivals, international students and non-union members are least likely to take steps to recover unpaid wages
Among those who had arrived within 3 years of the survey, the longer participants had been in Australia the more likely they had taken action at some point to recover unpaid wages. This may have been due to increased knowledge of workplace rights, connections to support and/or awareness of avenues for redress which all increase over time spent in Australia. However, the impact of these factors is limited: even among participants who had been in Australia for at least 3 years, only 16% had tried to recover their wages.
Figure 3. Underpaid participants who tried to recover unpaid wages for any job, by year of arrival (n=4,813).
Notes: Sample is participants who reported knowing they had been underpaid in any job in Australia. Percentages are of participants in each year of arrival.
Among 3,837 participants who held a Student visa at the time of the survey and indicated they had been underpaid in Australia, 14% had tried to recover unpaid wages (noting that the underpayment may have occurred on a Student visa or another visa). In contrast, among 133 participants who held a Working Holiday visa at the time of the survey, 22% had taken steps to recover unpaid wages.
Unsurprisingly, a greater proportion of union members had taken action to recover unpaid wages than non-union members. 343 participants who indicated that they had been underpaid in any job in Australia also indicated that they had been a union member. A quarter of these participants (24%) had tried to recover wages owed to them, compared with 13% of participants who had never joined a union.
Figure 4. Underpaid participants who tried to recover unpaid wages for any job, by whether they had ever been a union member in Australia (n=4,783)
Notes: Sample is participants who reported knowing they had been underpaid in any job in Australia.
We found no difference between men and women: 14% of each had tried to recover their wages and 11% of people who were non-binary or another gender had tried to recover unpaid wages. Other factors that did not affect participants’ likelihood to try to recover unpaid wages included their age and current state in which they lived.