About the survey
This report is the second in a series drawing on the Migrant Justice Institute’s (MJI) 2024 National Temporary Migrant Work Survey – the largest empirical study of migrants’ experiences of work in Australia and the first to be conducted post-COVID. A full description of the survey’s design, dissemination, data cleaning and limitations is set out in the first report in the series, Off the Books: Inside Australia's hidden system of migrant worker exploitation (Off the Books), and on MJI’s website.1 A summary is provided below.
This report was supported by the National Action Plan to Combat Modern Slavery 2020-2025 grant program funded by the Australian government, by Minderoo Foundation's Walk Free initiative and by the Migrant Workers Centre Vic.
To view the details of contributors to this report, see the Acknowledgements in the full PDF report.
The survey
The survey was an anonymous online questionnaire available in English, Mandarin, Spanish, Nepali, Tamil and Arabic. It was open between 8 July and 31 August 2024 to anyone aged 18 years and over who had worked in Australia while holding a temporary visa. Ethics approval was obtained from the Human Research Ethics Committee at UNSW Sydney and ratified by the University of Technology Sydney Human Research Ethics Committee. Participants who completed the survey could enter a prize draw. Contact details provided for the draw could not be linked to survey responses.
The survey contained 76 multiple choice questions, plus follow-up questions for some participants, 12 questions that allowed discursive responses, and a final open text question.
The survey was also designed as an information and empowerment tool. After several questions about knowledge of employment rights and entitlements, participants were shown the correct answer, and at the end they were directed to a referral portal with information on where to get help.
Responses and data cleaning
Of 16,727 responses received, 4,644 were removed because they did not meet the eligibility criteria, and a further 2,120 were excluded as potential bots. This left 9,963 valid responses. This report draws on the numerical survey data as well as analysis of the open responses, including responses of 3,656 participants who answered the final open text question, and open responses to 12 other survey questions.
Methodological limitations
The key limitations, as discussed in full in Off the Books, include:
- The risk of non-genuine responses in an anonymous online format, which was reduced by randomising response order, removing duplicate entries and screening extensively for bots;
- Over-representation of international students (over 8,000 respondents) relative to other visa cohorts, due to dissemination through education providers, and of migrants active on the social media platforms used for promotion;
- The survey's availability in only six languages, and possible differences in how translated terms were understood;
- The likely under-representation of the most vulnerable and least-networked migrants; and
- Possible self-selection among migrants motivated to share poor experiences, though this was mitigated by the alternate motivation established by the prize draw.
We concluded that given that random sampling of temporary visa holders is impracticable, the survey remains an effective way to reach large numbers of diverse migrants and shed light on their experiences of workplace exploitation.
Structure of survey questions on responses to underpayment
Off the Books reported on the section of the National Temporary Migrant Work Survey concerning wage rates and other working conditions experienced by participants in their lowest paid job in Australia while working on a temporary visa in 2023-2024.
Following the questions on participants’ lowest paid job, participants were asked whether they knew the minimum wage and the minimum wage for casual employees. They were then told that the National Minimum Wage in Australia at the time of the survey was $24.10/hour for workers who are 21 or above, and that casual workers were entitled to $30.13/hour in lieu of fixed hours, paid leave and a guarantee of ongoing work.
Later in the survey, participants were given the following prompt: ‘The legal minimum wage in Australia is $24.10 an hour but you are probably owed a higher rate’. They were then asked ‘If you have been paid less than you were owed in any job, have you tried or will you try to recover the money you are owed?’.
4,029 participants (45%) indicated that they did not believe they had been underpaid in any job in Australia. (Our findings from Off the Books indicate that many of these participants did not realise that they had in fact been underpaid – two thirds (65%) of employees were paid less than their entitlements in their lowest paid job in 2023-24.2) Nevertheless, since these participants were not aware that they had been underpaid, they were asked no further questions in relation to their response to underpayment, and are excluded from analysis in this report.
This report considers the other 4,835 participants who indicated that they had been underpaid at some point during their time in Australia. For those who indicated they had tried to recover their unpaid wages, it examines the actions they took and related outcomes. For those who indicated they had not tried to recover unpaid wages, it explores their reasons for remaining silent.
Participant demographics
We received 9,963 valid responses from participants who had worked in Australia on a temporary visa at any time. A detailed demographic profile of these participants is set out on our website.
Participants were located across all states and territories at the time of the survey. The majority (7,305 participants; 86%) were located in major cities. Around one in nine (980 participants; 11%) were located in Inner Regional Australia. The remaining 251 participants (3%) were located in Outer Regional, Remote or Very Remote Australia.
Participants were nationals of 140 countries, with the largest cohorts from India (16%), China (12%) and Nepal (9%).
A majority had arrived in Australia within 18 months of the survey, including 2,075 (21%) who were in their first six months in Australia. 76% had been in Australia for 2.5 years or less at the time of the survey.
Participants were required to be at least 18 years old in order to participate in the survey. Thirty-four percent of participants were aged between 23 and 27. About a quarter were aged 18-22 (23%) and a further two-fifths were aged 28 years or older (43%). Substantially more women (57%) than men (42%) participated in the survey.
Four in five participants (80%; 7,948) held a Student (subclass 500) visa at the time of the survey. This reflects a robust sample that is broadly representative of international students in Australia at the time of the survey. Among non-student visa holders, the largest cohorts held Temporary Graduate (subclass 485) visas (6%, 579), Working Holiday (subclass 417/462) visas (3%, 259), skilled (2%, 154), and bridging visas (4%, 385). A further 6% were on a range of other visas. There were 263 secondary visa holders.
The heavy weighting towards international students makes it difficult to generalise to all categories of visa holders. The non-student part of the cohort is not necessarily representative of the broader population of people who work while holding a temporary visa in Australia. Nevertheless, and given the challenges in collecting data from this diverse group of workers, the findings in this report are illustrative of the experiences of many temporary migrants who were working in Australia up to and including 2024.