‘Too much to lose’
The systems that keep exploited migrants silent
Back to report home page Download PDF
08

Recommendations

These recommendations address the need to strengthen measures that hold exploitative employers to account at scale, and enable workers to report non-compliance and recover their outstanding entitlements. The recommendations draw and expand upon those made in Off the Books.

Recommendations to Commonwealth Government

Reform area 1 · Migration settings

Reform migration settings linked to exploitation

Fear of jeopardising workers’ current visa status and/or future immigration pathway was one of the greatest barriers to participants’ pursuing claims against an exploitative employer. Migration settings must be reformed to remove the adverse immigration consequences of reporting underpayment, to enable workers to proactively take action to recover unpaid wages and to protect workers who participate in government compliance activities (by the FWO, ABF or other agencies).

1

Strengthen and make permanent the visa protection pilots to protect workers who report abuse

Government already has tools to ameliorate migrants’ fear of immigration consequences if they report abuse. From July 2024, Government introduced the Strengthening Reporting Protections Pilot and Workplace Justice Visa Pilot which strengthen protection for workers who have experienced exploitation.93 Both can enable migrant workers to safely pursue claims against dishonest employers without risking their visa.

Government now funds Migrant Worker Centres through the trade and labour councils in each state and territory to support migrant workers, including certifying claims as ‘Accredited Third Parties’ (ATPs) for the visa protection pilots. A number of unions are also able to provide these certifications.

However, other than two community legal centres in NSW and Victoria, no other CLCs, Legal Aid offices or university legal services have been authorised to assist their clients to access the visa protections that would enable their clients to safely proceed with claims for unpaid wages and other labour rights breaches.94

Government should make these pilots permanent. It should ensure timely access to the protections as intended.

Government should also make the visa and SRP more widely accessible nationwide by expanding the number and range of ATPs that can certify claims to ensure equal access across all states and territories, including for non-union members.95

This should include enabling legal services on university campuses to provide certifications for international students who wish to report exploitation and claim their unpaid wages, but will only do so with an assurance that this will not result in cancellation of their student visa. Government could consider reforms that authorise university legal services to provide certifications to international students for the SRP only, since the overwhelming majority would not be eligible for the Workplace Justice Visa.

Government should also expand the definition of a ‘workplace exploitation matter’ to reflect the full range of common workplace matters, including General Protections in cases of employer retaliation. It is also critical that eligibility for the Workplace Justice visa be extended beyond 28 days before or after visa expiry, and that the visa be available to Bridging visa holders and undocumented workers.96

2

Address coercive power of employer sponsorship

The survey data reinforce that actual and potential employer sponsorship of migrant visas creates an overwhelming power disparity that drives exploitation and coerces worker silence. This power is wielded not only through sponsorship itself, but also through the promise of future sponsorship to migrants on a range of unsponsored visas.

Government should consider alternative models that reduce employer leverage by removing employer sponsorship requirements from a range of temporary visas,97 including through industry or sectoral sponsorship models.98

Government should also look to remove the leverage employers wield as gatekeepers to permanent residence. Precedents for this already exist not only in independent skilled points-tested visas but other visa pathways.

For instance, holders of provisional Employer Sponsored Regional (subclass 494) visas (that is similar to the temporary Skills in Demand (subclass 482) visa) become eligible for permanent residency through the Skilled Regional (subclass 191) visa after three years’ work for a regional employer, while living in a regional area, with no additional requirement for employer sponsorship or nomination. This approach could be replicated across other pathways, including the standard pathway from the 482 visa to permanent 186 visa, such that qualifying work experience gained across multiple employers establishes eligibility to self-sponsor for a permanent visa.

Overall migration levels could be moderated through planning levels or queuing arrangements rather than employer sponsorship. There is no requirement for the worker to remain with the sponsoring employer once the 186 visa is granted. This diminishes the justification for employer sponsorship as an indication of the worker’s perceived value in addressing a skills shortage, when compared with the risk to the many migrants subjected to long-term exploitation on the journey to employer-promised permanent residence.

In the immediate term, Government should create conditions that enable it to enforce the recently-introduced criminal offence of using a promise of sponsorship to coerce temporary visa holders to accept exploitative work arrangements.99 Resources should be allocated to prosecuting the offence. Government should identify appropriate protections and benefits for migrant workers to report employers, recognising that it is essential to prosecuting the offence, but may jeopardise the migrant’s visa and immigration pathway. This should include identifying possible immigration concessions that would make reporting safe and worthwhile for exploited migrants. Recognising this offence will remain difficult to prosecute, Government should explore other ways to reduce the leverage that employers can wield as possible future sponsors.

3

Ensure undocumented workers are not subjected to immigration enforcement without labour enforcement

In 2026, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke announced new resourcing of detention and removal of people who had overstayed their visa in Australia.100 Removing workers who lack permission to remain and work in Australia on its own does not address the exploitative workplaces into which other undocumented workers may move. This resourcing of immigration compliance provides a critical opportunity to strengthen enforcement of labour protections - to recover entitlements for this particularly vulnerable workforce and hold non-compliant employers to account. This approach is especially important in light of laws passed by this government in 2023 and 2024 that explicitly confirmed that workplace protections in Australia apply to all workers regardless of their status.101

Recognising that a migrant's removal can interfere with their ability to enforce their labour rights, the International Labour Organisation’s guidance to states provides that:

any migrant worker, regardless of status, who leaves the country of employment should also be entitled to: any outstanding remuneration for work performed, including severance payments normally due; benefits for employment injuries suffered; compensation in lieu of any holiday entitlement acquired but not used (in accordance with national practice); and reimbursement of certain social security contributions.102

Government should extend access to the Workplace Justice visa to undocumented workers. This could be done by Australian Border Force officers routinely referring apprehended undocumented migrants to a state Migrant Worker Centre (MWC), other Accredited Third Party or the FWO for certification of their labour claim, and granting of a short Workplace Justice visa to instigate a legal matter prior to the migrant’s departure from Australia.

Alternatively, the Australian Border Force should refer undocumented migrants for screening of labour claims similar to screening of trafficking claims by the Australian Red Cross. This could be done via referral to the Red Cross, the FWO or a local MWC in order to commence proceedings against the employer prior to removal or voluntary departure.

4

Consider increasing cap on student working hours

Condition 8105 attaches to most student visas, restricting the visa holder’s work to 48 hours per fortnight while a student’s course is in session.103 This survey has revealed widespread sentiment among international students that this work restriction can limit their access to lawfully paid jobs, pushes them into ‘cash jobs’ and then, in a vicious cycle, causes them to work more hours than permitted to make ends meet on these unlawfully low wages.

In Off the Books we recommended that Government explore increasing this work limitation above 48 hours per fortnight, in order to reduce exploitation risks and respond to increased cost of living in Australia.104

To this end, Government should evaluate the impact of increased cost of living on international students, the impact of the work restriction on employer willingness to hire international students in lawfully paid jobs, and the impact of widespread underpayment and mistreatment in the jobs in which most international students work. This includes the consequences of poor working conditions and financial distress on international students’ studies, experience in Australia, and mental health.

Reform area 2 · Labour enforcement

Mobilise cross-government regulatory levers to scale labour enforcement

A strategic approach to labour compliance can be effective only if employers believe there is a realistic likelihood that both the exploitation could be detected, and that meaningful consequences will flow. This section recommends measures to scale up detection by the Fair Work Ombudsman to the level needed to create meaningful deterrence. FWO’s enforcement activity and deterrent impact could be more effective if FWO detection of significant noncompliance routinely resulted in sanctions in the migration domain.

5

Invest in the Fair Work Ombudsman’s capability to operate at the scale needed to create employer expectations of accountability

Despite the systemic scale of migrant exploitation across Australian workplaces, the FWO’s budget has only increased marginally in the 3 years since 2024.105 Although the regulator has substantially increased proactive civil investigations over this time, the FWO remains unable to investigate, and pursue compliance activities, in a sufficient number of workplaces to disrupt employers’ perception of unfettered power over migrants in Australia.

There is a fundamental discrepancy between the broadly-promoted advice to migrant workers to call the regulator for assistance with problems at work, and the number of individual workers that the FWO has capacity to meaningfully assist. Many survey participants expressed disappointment and frustration when, after reporting alleged noncompliance, the FWO declined to investigate their matter.

Until the FWO’s capability to pursue a greater number of worker requests for assistance is increased, the FWO should review its communications (and those shared by many government agencies, universities and other stakeholders) to establish realistic expectations of the assistance the regulator is likely to provide.

6

The Fair Work Ombudsman should invest in addressing migrant sham contracting and ensure misclassified workers can access assistance

In Off the Books we found one in three survey participants were engaged on an ABN in their lowest paid job in 2023-24. 85% of ABN workers were paid below the minimum entitlements they would have had as an employee, including 43% paid below the National Minimum Wage.106

The majority (61%) of participants on ABNs were in jobs where many were likely deliberately misclassified employees (washing dishes, waiting tables, working behind a retail counter).107 Sham contracting of visa holders appears to now be a systemic practice to evade basic employment entitlements and escape regulatory oversight.

The FWO generally does not have jurisdiction over independent contractors.108 Many migrants engaged on an ABN are unaware that if, in reality, their work arrangement is that of an employee, they are entitled to employment protections under the Fair Work Act and fall within the FWO’s jurisdiction.

Misclassified employees seeking to pursue unpaid wages in court or other forums must first demonstrate that their work arrangement meets the criteria for employment. This is a significant, and generally insurmountable, hurdle for most migrant workers. It should not be a hurdle in relation to migrant workers’ access to assistance from the FWO.

When a visa holder on an ABN contacts the FWO for assistance, the FWO should be empowered to apply a presumption that a visa holder on an ABN is an employee for the purpose of providing assistance. For the purpose of a FWO compliance notice, the onus of proof could be shifted such that if the legal status of a worker is in dispute, the party asserting that the worker is an independent contractor is required to demonstrate that the worker is not, in fact, an employee under the Fair Work Act.109 There could be a carve-out for certain industries such as delivery and rideshare where workers are generally engaged as an independent contractor under law.110

To tackle the widespread sham contracting exploitation tactic at scale, Government should resource the FWO to provide direct assistance to migrant workers to demonstrate they have been misclassified.111 It should provide the regulator with additional resources to conduct education campaigns for visa holders and businesses on misclassification and sham contracting in priority industries, underscoring that misclassified employees on ABNs may access FWO assistance to recover unpaid entitlements.

7

Strengthen the link between employer sponsorship eligibility and workplace compliance

Australian Border Force has increased its monitoring of migrant sponsors, including unannounced visits and inspections of hundreds of workplaces across the country, resulting in hundreds of employer sanctions in 2025-26.112

Government should extend these efforts to prevent businesses from sponsoring migrants if they are found to have breached workplace responsibilities in relation to any workers, rather than confining this to breach of sponsorship obligations. ‘Adverse information’ is considered by the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) when determining a new visa sponsorship application or nomination, including noncompliance by a company as well as its officers and directors.113 At a practical level, Government should develop mechanisms to systematically marshal information on workplace noncompliance for the purpose of DHA decision-making via structured information-sharing with the FWO and other agencies, courts and commissions.

The Prohibited Employer Register could greatly assist with sponsorship determinations if its use were exponentially increased (see next recommendation).

Adverse information could also relate to prevalence of migrant exploitation at an industry level, with a higher level of scrutiny applied to sponsorship or nomination applications for industries with known systemic workplace noncompliance in relation to visa holders, such as hospitality.114 Measures should be adopted to protect existing sponsored workers and other visa holder employees when an employer sponsor is barred from sponsorship.

8

Use the Prohibited Employer Register at scale for Fair Work Act contraventions

In July 2024, Government introduced the Prohibited Employer Register to prevent demonstrated exploitative employers from repeating their conduct in relation to other migrant workers.115 The Register prohibits employers, sponsors and third parties who have seriously, deliberately or repeatedly broken a migration, employment or criminal law from employing additional temporary visa holders for a period of time.

The Prohibited Employer Register is substantially underutilised. In contrast to the increased ABF enforcement activities in relation to migrant sponsors and the Register of Sanctioned Sponsors,116 in over 2 years since the Prohibited Employer Register was established, only a single hospitality business has been placed on the register.117

Use of this regulatory measure should be dramatically increased to provide a sufficient deterrent to employers who fear losing access to migrant labour generally, and the reputational damage which flows from appearance on the public register.

The DHA should coordinate with the FWO to ensure that all relevant businesses that have seriously or repeatedly contravened the Fair Work Act in relation to migrant workers are prohibited from employing vulnerable migrant workers for an appropriate period. It should work with FWO and industry groups to publicise placement of businesses on the register.

Government should establish that orders by the forthcoming Fair Work Court can result in placement of sanctioned employers on the Prohibited Employer Register.

Reform area 3 · Information and legal support

Invest in migrant information and legal support

Evaluate gaps and increase funding for legal assistance for all migrant workers on temporary visas, establish a new wage and superannuation calculation assistance, and address migrant knowledge barriers to accessing justice.

9

Evaluate gaps and increase funding for legal assistance for migrant workers

Government and service providers should collaborate to identify gaps in legal assistance for migrant workers across geographical regions in Australia. This includes dedicated and coordinated support for international students (see separate recommendation below).

The federal and state governments should increase funding for legal assistance providers, including community legal services, legal aid, migrant worker centres, and dedicated migrant worker support within the FWO to address these gaps, so vulnerable workers can receive tailored support throughout a wage claim or at key stages.118 Services must be adequately resourced to ensure accessibility in regional locations where exploitation risks are especially high for workers who are especially isolated and alone.

To enable service providers to effectively assist exploited migrants, the Commonwealth Government should urgently expand the list of organisations that may provide certifications for migrant workers to access visa protections that many need in order to pursue a labour claim (see separate recommendation above).

10

Provide specialised wage and superannuation calculation assistance

Government should establish and fund a Wages and Super Calculation service that provides workers with free and accurate estimates of unpaid wages and superannuation based on their job details and daily working hours. The service could work with existing providers and be coordinated by the Fair Work Commission, FWO, new Fair Work Court or a non-government organisation such as a community legal centre. Specialised support should also help workers:

  • Identify and substantiate all potential claims;
  • Identify the correct employer; and
  • Calculate the underpayment where it appears that the worker may have a claim.

Services assisting workers with bona fide claims should receive support from the FWO, including a ‘fast track’ to assistance from the regulator.119

11

Address migrant knowledge barriers to accessing justice

Various information campaigns, by government agencies, universities and others, have sought to improve migrants’ knowledge about the National Minimum Wage and other basic labour rights. However, these are typically at a single point in time or on an ad hoc basis.

Government should provide worker rights education that is accessible and relevant to different cohorts of migrants at different touchpoints through their migration journey. This includes embedding this information in the visa grant communication process predeparture, as well as in post-arrival processes, and on a regular basis through universities and other institutions engaging large numbers of visa holders. Specific recommendations to the international education sector are detailed in the next recommendation.

In addition to basic information about wages, entitlements and working conditions, information provided to migrant workers should include:

  • How to create evidence of hours worked and payment received, especially in the absence of accurate payslips (e.g. text messages with employer);
  • Common misconceptions, including clarifying that visa holders are entitled to the same wages as Australian workers and that a worker has not broken the law if they are paid in cash or knowingly underpaid;
  • The legal implications of payment of wages in cash, including tax liability and the tax-free threshold;
  • Confirmation that misclassified employees are protected by the Fair Work Act even when engaged on an ABN. (In exercising its new jurisdiction over wage claims, the Fair Work Commission should provide clear instructions on setting out a misclassification claim, with a checklist that sets out the grounds for classification of work as employment or contract for services).
  • The availability of the visa protections pilot;
  • How to access wage-recovery processes, and where and how workers can seek assistance, including the availability and importance of legal advice and representation (through local Community Legal Centres, Migrant Worker Centres, student legal services and Legal Aid) and relevant unions in key industries with high concentrations of migrant workers; and
  • The possibility of taking action to recover wages after a worker has left a job.
Reform area 4 · International students

Develop a targeted response to exploitation of international students

Unlike other migrant cohorts, international students are structurally connected to key intervention points via education providers, student networks and others. This presents a significant opportunity to address exploitation and lack of reporting. Neither Government nor the education sector has considered how to leverage these channels.

12

Curb international student exploitation through a new multi-agency program in collaboration with the international education sector

Currently, universities and other education providers provide no structured support to international students to address workplace exploitation. Instead, government and education providers disseminate information, primarily at orientation, directing students to contact the FWO.120 However, only 3% of underpaid international students actually contacted the FWO. Given the regulator’s known resource constraints and strategic approach to compliance, most students should not realistically expect to receive individual assistance via the FWO.

We recommend the Government commission a systemic review of potential interventions to address international student exploitation, and develop a multi-agency approach in collaboration with the international education sector, legal service providers and unions. This could include:

  • Produce information on workplace rights and where to get help, with optimised content, delivery strategies and timing based on research on international student experiences and preferences;
  • Develop a coordinated plan for government, education providers, education agents, diplomatic missions and other stakeholders to deliver information at key intervention points starting pre-arrival;
  • Universities and larger providers provide a single contact point for workplace problems, with referrals to employment law advice on-campus, or via structured partnerships with external providers (CLCs, Migrant Worker Centres and the FWO). The FWO should be funded to provide dedicated support to these services.
  • DHA should accredit all student legal services to access the Strengthened Reporting Protections Pilot.
  • Other government agencies should consider further interventions (e.g. Department of Education regarding education provider responsibilities; ATO regarding student support and compliance for unpaid superannuation and sham contracting; DEWR regarding barriers to labour enforcement; AGD regarding accessible wage recovery processes; AFP regarding support for criminal exploitation and modern slavery risks).
Reform area 5 · Wage recovery

Establish accessible wage-recovery pathways

Data in this report and our All Work No Pay report indicate that migrants are not accessing legal processes to recover unpaid wages.121 Procedural requirements in the small claims process make filing and pursuing a claim very difficult for migrant workers without legal assistance. It is especially challenging for workers in insecure jobs to evidence underpayment without accurate employer pay records, and enforcing a wage judgment against a recalcitrant employer is impossible for most workers. It is also very difficult to pursue claims from abroad for migrants whose visa expires. We recommend several reforms to reduce barriers to pursuing judicial remedies and increase the likelihood of successful wage recovery.

13

Establish accessible administrative and judicial wage-recovery forums

Our All Work No Pay report and previous reports recommended expansion of the Fair Work Commission’s (FWC) jurisdiction to include wage and entitlement claims, alongside a new Fair Work Court.122 In 2026, Government announced the establishment of a Fair Work Court co-located with the FWC, with new powers in relation to wage claims.123 We commend this initiative, and recommend that this proposal be implemented.

The design of the processes and structure of the new Fair Work Court and new FWC jurisdiction for wage claims should ensure it is accessible and effectively delivers outcomes to migrant workers, including:

  • Resourcing of legal advice and representation and individualised assistance to identify and calculate wage claims (see above);
  • A court-based duty lawyer or dedicated duty solicitor service to help self-represented litigants navigate hearing-day processes and understand any required follow-up action.124
  • Strong client-centred case management assistance for workers and employers;
  • Mandatory timetabling directions providing a fast-track approach for mediation for applicants on a temporary visa;
  • A presumption in the worker’s favour applied during conciliation and by the Court where an employer has failed to provide payslips or there is evidence of fraudulent records of wages or hours;
  • Equal access costs.125
14

Improve workers’ access to evidence to demonstrate underpayment through compulsory provision of a Statement of Working Conditions

Our Off the Books report documented systemic employer practices that deprive workers of evidence needed to demonstrate underpayment (e.g. not providing a written contract setting out conditions of employment, cash wages, lack of payslips).126 Government should consider a new requirement for employers to provide employees with a Statement of Working Conditions identifying their legal entitlements, including hours, pay, leave entitlements, and job duties. Failure to provide this Statement would lead to a reversed onus of proof in wage claims.127

15

Establish mechanisms for workers to recover wages when the employer will not pay

Many workers indicated that they were unable to recover unpaid wages because their employer liquidated, disappeared or could not be compelled to pay a wage judgment. The debt of unpaid wages should not be borne by a vulnerable migrant worker - the party least able to carry it. Government should address this systems failure through three critical reforms.

First, Government should extend the Fair Entitlements Guarantee scheme to migrant workers to provide redress for unpaid wages when their employer liquidates, as is provided to residents and citizens in Australia.128 Government accepted this recommendation of the Migrant Worker Taskforce when it came into power,129 but has failed to implement its commitment.

Second, Government should establish and fund a wage guarantee scheme to ensure that any worker with a wage judgment in their favour receives their lawful entitlements if the employer becomes insolvent, refuses to pay or cannot be located.130 Funds for this scheme could be raised through various means, including from Fair Work Act penalties which would otherwise have been paid to Consolidated Revenue, administered by the FWO.

Third, Government should consider examples from other jurisdictions that enable workers to recover unpaid wages from lead contractors or other entities higher up in a supply chain where the employer cannot be compelled to pay.131

Reform area 6 · Supply chains

Strengthen supply chain accountability

Following the release of this report we will publish a separate Practical Guidance setting out specific insights and detailed recommendations for industry. This section focuses on legislative reforms to strengthen corporate accountability for wage theft.

16

Introduce a risk-based corporate due diligence obligation to identify and address forced labour

In July 2026, Government proposed the introduction of a new criminal ‘failure to prevent’ modern slavery in supply chains offence, with a defence available where a corporation has taken ‘reasonable steps’ to prevent modern slavery.132

In October, the Australian Anti-Slavery Commissioner released a paper highlighting concerns with introducing a criminal offence alone.133 The Commissioner instead proposed a broader, graduated regulatory framework centred on a civil modern slavery due diligence obligation overseen by a responsive regulator and accessible pathways to remedy for victims. The Commissioner recommended that any criminal offence should complement the due diligence obligation, target the most serious conduct and be carefully designed to incentivise good practices relating to due diligence.

MJI supports this proposed approach as a more effective response to regulating business responses to modern slavery risk than a criminal offence alone. In line with the Anti-Slavery Commissioner’s recommendations, the Act should be amended to include a civil modern slavery due diligence obligation that requires large businesses to take reasonable steps to identify and address the most severe risks of modern slavery in their operations and supply chains. This should include proactively detecting underpayment and other relevant contraventions of the Fair Work Act that point to modern slavery risk. Responsibilities should be heightened for their operations within Australia.

17

Any ‘reasonable steps’ defence should have increased expectations for Australia-based operations and supply chains

If Government introduces a criminal offence with a reasonable steps defence, it should articulate higher minimum expectations for ‘reasonable steps’ in relation to a corporation’s Australia-based operations and supply chains, given that higher visibility and influence would be reasonably expected in the Australian context than in foreign jurisdictions. This should include an expectation that corporations address significant workplace exploitation risks that are known to be associated with forced labour, including underpayment of migrant workers.

The survey findings underscore that the overwhelming majority of migrant workers do not report workplace exploitation.

Effective modern slavery due diligence therefore requires an investment in worker engagement channels that migrants view as safe and accessible and provide meaningful remedy. A corporation’s establishment of grievance and audit systems that fail to identify labour exploitation risks in known high-risk industries in Australia should not be considered ‘reasonable steps’. As outlined in the Commissioner’s paper, ‘reasonable steps’ should include, for example, meaningful engagement with stakeholders including workers and civil society.

18

Consider introducing civil accessorial liability provisions to expand corporate accountability for labour noncompliance in operations and supply chains

To complement the proposed modern slavery framework, Government should consider strengthening existing provisions in the Fair Work Act which hold Australian businesses and individuals civilly liable for their involvement in contraventions of the Act in relation to non-direct employees. There are three areas in which accessorial liability could be extended to increase transparency and accountability for workplace exploitation in Australian supply chains.

First, Government should consider amending the current accessorial liability provision in s 550.134 The requirement that a third party have ‘actual knowledge’ of a contravention should be replaced with a requirement that liability arise where the third party knew or could reasonably be expected to have known that the contravention may occur. Like the proposed criminal offence, a defence should be available to accessories that can establish that they took reasonable steps to prevent the contravention.

Government should also consider extending the responsible franchisor provisions beyond the franchise context, to apply more broadly to supply chain and subcontracting arrangements. Where there is a chain of two or more arrangements for the supply of goods or services, lead firms should be liable for any contraventions occurring in their chain that they knew about, or could reasonably be expected to have known about, unless they can prove a reasonable steps defence.

Government should also consider expanding accountability for sham contracting within franchises, business operations and supply chains that obtain unfair financial gains from this practice, even if they are not directly involved in the arrangements. This would incentivise lead firms to undertake due diligence to identify use of workers on ABNs as a strategy for subverting Australian workplace protections, especially in relation to temporary visa holders.

With State and Territory Governments

Reform area 7 · Licensing schemes

Leverage licensing schemes to drive workplace compliance

19

Introduce a national labour hire licensing scheme, or in the absence of a national scheme, establish and coordinate schemes across every state and territory

We did not ask survey participants whether they were employed directly or via labour hire because we believed this question would be difficult for some participants to understand and as a result the data would be unreliable. However, multiple government inquiries have documented significant exploitation of migrant workers engaged through unscrupulous and unregulated labour hire providers, particularly in horticulture where small operators disappear overnight and cannot be held to account.135 This is a clear enforcement gap that must be urgently filled in order to systemically address underpayment and exploitation of migrant workers in Australia.

The Commonwealth Government should establish a national labour hire licensing regime to hold these providers to account for Fair Work Act noncompliance, enable businesses to reliably source workers from reputable compliant labour hire providers, and remove fly-by-night operators.136

Establishment of a licensing scheme creates a strong disincentive against workplace noncompliance because, if enforced by a strong regulator, it could result in the business losing its licence to operate as a labour hire provider.

Failing the establishment of a national scheme, every state and territory should establish a scheme at the state level, with harmonisation across jurisdictions wherever possible. Each scheme should be established with a regulator that is adequately empowered and resourced to ensure workplace compliance by licenced providers, reviewed regularly at the point of registration renewal as well as in response to complaints and investigations.

20

Leverage licensing regimes in other domains to drive employer compliance with Commonwealth and state laws in relation to migrant workers

Explore areas in which Commonwealth, state and local governments provide licenses or operational accreditation to businesses that could be used to leverage compliance with workplace responsibilities to vulnerable workers and prevention of modern slavery. The risk of losing an operational license based on noncompliance with workplace laws could be used as a powerful lever to deter noncompliance.

Our report, Migrant Workers’ Access to Justice for Wage Theft: A global study of promising initiatives,137 discusses numerous state and city initiatives in the United States in which regulatory frameworks limit an employer’s ability to do business if it does not comply with federal workplace laws.

For example, under the Permit Enforcement Program, the County of Santa Clara in California may temporarily suspend or revoke a restaurant business’ food health permit if a business does not comply with an existing court judgment for underpayment or other workplace violations.138 The program is administered through a collaboration between the Santa Clara Office of Labor Standards and the Santa Clara County Department of Environmental Health - Consumer and Environmental Protection Agency.

Our relationship changed when she started to sponsor me. I had to stay back more often to finish work and couldn’t say no. I couldn’t complain because it was a company of 2 people – me and her. I couldn’t quit because otherwise I would have to leave the country during the lockdowns.
30-year-old Malaysian woman in VIC
University of Technology Sydney UNSW Sydney
UTS Law Faculty and UNSW Faculty of Law & Justice are proud supporters of the Migrant Justice Institute. MJI is a charity registered with ACNC. ABN 84654507758.
ACNC Registered Charity
Be the first to know when we publish new research

Get early access to new reports, hear about policy wins first, and stay connected to the fight for migrant worker justice.

Subscribe
Off The Books report cover ‘Right or wrong, just accept it’ report cover
Migrant Workers’ Access to Justice for Wage Theft report cover All Work, No Pay report cover
Migrant Justice Institute

The Migrant Justice Institute respectfully acknowledges the Gadigal and Bedegal peoples of the Eora Nation and the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nations, the traditional owners and custodians of the land on which we work. We pay our respects to their elders past and present and acknowledge that sovereignty was never ceded.

Contents