Actions and outcomes
Actions taken by the small proportion of individual migrant workers who sought to recover wages, and outcomes
The 687 participants who indicated that they had tried to recover unpaid wages were asked whom they contacted for help, and were able to select one or more organisations or people. 636 participants answered this question. The full cohort of 8,789 participants were also asked a further set of questions in relation to their awareness of, and attitudes towards, the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO).
Demanding wages from employer
A worker may directly approach their employer for unpaid wages and entitlements. This could take the form of a conversation or email to the worker’s supervisor or human resources (HR) department, a complaint through a company grievance platform, or a formal letter of demand to the company from the worker or their legal or union representative.
Approaching a supervisor at work
Among participants who knew they had been underpaid, only 4% indicated that they had sought help to recover their unpaid wages through a ‘supervisor or HR at my work’.
The higher the migrant’s wage bracket in their lowest paid job in 2023-24, the more likely they had raised an underpayment issue with their ‘supervisor or HR’ in that job or any other job. Only 2% of those paid below $20 per hour and 3% of those paid below the National Minimum Wage ($20-22 per hour) in their lowest paid job in 2023-24 had ever raised an underpayment issue with their supervisor or HR officer in Australia. In contrast 7% of those paid at least the casual minimum wage ($29 or more per hour) in their lowest paid job had contacted a supervisor or HR officer for help with underpayment in a job in Australia.
Issuing letter of demand
A letter of demand to the employer sets out the amount the worker is owed and is generally a precursor to filing a claim for unpaid wages and entitlements in court. A letter of demand may be issued by a lawyer, union or other representative of the worker, or by the worker directly. Because it conveys the possibility of litigation, a letter of demand can sometimes result in settlement of the matter without needing to progress to court.
Many migrant workers would require assistance to calculate the wages they are owed and compose a letter of demand.82 We did not specifically ask participants whether they had issued their employer with a letter of demand, but we asked whether they had sought help from legal services, a union and others who could have helped them to try to recover unpaid wages.
Seeking assistance from legal service providers
38 participants indicated they had contacted a Community Legal Centre (CLC) (this was less than 1% of those who indicated they were underpaid). 21 contacted a law firm.
Seeking assistance from a union
37 participants (less than 1%) contacted a union for assistance with unpaid wages which may have included issuing a letter of demand or other direct engagement with the employer on the worker’s behalf.
International students seeking assistance from education provider and others
Among 3,837 current international students, less than 1% contacted staff at their university or college (24 participants), which might have included university legal services (a further <1% contacted their Education Agent (26 participants)).
Legal claim before a court
For wage claims up to $100,000, a worker can bring a case against their employer in the small claims jurisdiction of the Federal Circuit Court and Family Court of Australia or lower state and territory courts.83 This jurisdiction is more informal than the Federal Court and is intended to make recovery of wages in court more accessible, and ensure claims are dealt with ‘efficiently’ and ‘expeditiously’, and ‘not subject to onerous procedural requirements’.84 However, only an extremely small number of workers across Australia take this step: in 2022-23, only 137 people attempted to recover their wages this way across the country.85
In 2024 we conducted a study of the accessibility of this small claims jurisdiction. In All Work No Pay: Improving the Legal System So Migrants Can Get the Wages they are Owed (2024), we concluded it is virtually impossible for most migrant workers to file and pursue a small claim without legal assistance.86 This is because of the complexity of procedural requirements. For instance, an applicant must correctly identify the legal entity of their employer as well as their own legal entitlements under the relevant award or enterprise agreement. They must also prepare necessary affidavits and execute formal legal service of relevant documents on the employer. In the context of an acute power imbalance in court between most migrant workers and their employers, even those few migrant workers who might be able to file a claim have an understandably bleak view of the risks and likelihood of success.
Out of 4,835 survey participants who knew they had been underpaid in Australia, only 17 individuals (0.4%) had attempted to recover their wages through a legal claim in a court.
Figure 8. Underpaid participants who tried to recover unpaid wages by going to court.
Notes: Sample is participants who indicated they knew they had been underpaid in Australia (n=4,835).
Of the 17 participants who went to court, 18% recovered all their wages and 41% recovered some.
Trade union
Across all survey participants, 7% stated that they had been a trade union member. This was around half of the proportion of employees across Australia who were union members in August 2024 (which was 13%), and around the same proportion of workers aged 20-24 across Australia who were members at the time (7%).87 It is higher than the proportion of migrants who reported they were union members in our 2016 survey (which was 4%).88 This relatively high incidence of union membership likely results from the assistance of some unions with dissemination of the survey.
Trade unions may assist workers to directly negotiate with the employer, file a claim in court, or approach the FWO. However, migrant workers are generally reluctant to proactively seek trade union assistance,89 though trade unions in some industries (such as meat, horticulture and commercial cleaning) have recruited and represented migrant workers with notable successes.
As noted above, among all survey participants who knew they were underpaid, 1% (37 individuals) contacted a trade union for help to recover unpaid wages.
These participants reported the highest proportions recovering either all or some of their unpaid wages (27% and 41%), compared with those who went to court (discussed above) or the FWO (discussed in the next section).
Industry-led grievance processes
Participants who indicated that they had worked in farm work or meat processing at any point in Australia were asked whether their company provided mechanisms to report problems, and could select ‘a business hotline’, an ‘app or online survey or website’, or ‘an independent investigator/auditor’. Participants could also select ‘I don’t know’ or ‘none of these’. 470 participants answered this question.
Around one in six participants (17%; 82 participants) indicated that their company provided at least one of the three reporting mechanisms. Each mechanism was selected by around 8% of participants, with some respondents indicating their employer had more than one mechanism.
The 82 participants whose employer had a reporting mechanism were asked whether they or anyone they know has used any of these mechanisms to report a problem. 27 participants (33%) indicated that they had or knew someone who had. 16 participants gave further information about the outcome. Of the 16, 12 indicated that the business took steps to investigate and/or there was some positive response. Three of the 16 recounted negative responses such as being bullied, or ‘they ignored and wanted to hide the issue’.
The findings suggest the majority of workers in farmwork and meat (83%) were unaware of any mechanism to report problems to their employer. However among the small cohort who used a mechanism themselves or knew someone who had, 44% reported that their company looked into the matter following the complaint.
The Fair Work Ombudsman
The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) is the principal avenue through which migrant workers may seek remedies for wage underpayment. The agency has made significant efforts to focus compliance activities on migrant workers, including numerous high-profile campaigns and inquiries.90 However, the FWO’s core functions are not directed to the large-scale provision of individual remedies. Rather, they are oriented to strategic enforcement and systemic deterrence of noncompliance.91
We asked the full cohort of survey participants about their awareness of the FWO and whether they would contact the FWO if they ‘had a problem at work to do with [their] wages or conditions’. We received 8,789 responses to this question. We then asked all participants whether they knew anyone who tried to recover their wages through the FWO, and the outcome.
Later in the survey, we asked survey participants who knew they were underpaid whether they had contacted the FWO for help to recover unpaid wages (or courts, unions etc).
This section presents data from each of these questions and considers the relationship between them.
Two in three migrants knew about the FWO, and awareness increases with time in Australia
Under two thirds (63%) of participants knew of the existence of the FWO at the time of the survey (5,516 participants). Over a third (37%) did not know about the FWO.
Figure 9. Awareness of the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) at the time of the survey (n=8,789)
Awareness of the existence of the FWO at the time of the survey progressively increased the longer the participant had been in Australia. Over three quarters of participants (77%) who had arrived in Australia 3 years or more before the survey were aware of the FWO, compared with less than half of participants (47%) who had arrived within 6 months of the survey in 2024.
Figure 10. Awareness of the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) at the time of the survey, by year of arrival (n=8,760).
Migrants who worked in insecure jobs and those who were more egregiously underpaid were less likely to know about the FWO
Although knowledge of the FWO increased with length of time in Australia, the participants who were the most egregiously underpaid in their lowest paid job in 2023-24 were consistently less aware of the FWO regardless of year of arrival.
Figure 11. Awareness of the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) at the time of the survey, by hourly wage bracket in the lowest paid job in 2023-24, and by year of arrival.
Notes: Sample is participants who arrived and worked in Australia in 2023–24 (n=4,032). Percentages are of participants in each wage bracket, and in each arrival year (2023, 2024), who were aware of the FWO. Hourly wage brackets refer to the participant’s hourly wage in their lowest-paid job in 2023–24.
Likewise, participants who were engaged in insecure work arrangements in their lowest paid job in 2023-24 were consistently less likely to be aware of the FWO than those in permanent employment, regardless of year of arrival. Among all participants regardless of year of arrival, those working on an ABN had the lowest levels of awareness of the FWO (60%), followed by those working as a casual employee (64%), with both substantially lower than awareness among employees in a permanent position (77%).
Figure 12. Awareness of the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) at the time of the survey, in the lowest paid job in 2023-24, and by structure of employment.
Notes: Sample is participants who arrived and worked in Australia in 2023–24 who answered the question about whether they were entitled to paid leave (n=3,411). Structure of employment (ABN, casual, permanent) refers to the participant’s employment arrangement in their lowest-paid job in 2023–24. Percentages are of participants in each employment structure who were aware of the FWO, and in each year of arrival. Employees who indicated they were entitled to sick leave and annual leave were deemed permanent; those who were not were deemed casual.
International students were less likely to know about the FWO than other visa holders
A smaller proportion of international students were aware of the FWO (59%), compared with Working Holiday Makers (65%), Temporary Graduate visa holders (81%) and skilled visa holders (82%).
Awareness of the FWO was similar among women (62%), men (64%) and participants who were non-binary or had another gender (61%).
Awareness of the FWO was especially low among Chinese nationals (48%).
Figure 13. Awareness of the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) at the time of the survey, by visa held at the time of survey (n=7,876)
Migrants’ awareness of, and openness to, contacting the FWO does not translate to actually contacting the FWO for help with unpaid wages
We asked all survey participants ‘Would you go to the Fair Work Ombudsman if you had a problem at work to do with your wages or conditions?’. Among the 5,516 participants who were aware of the existence of the FWO, 80% said that they would contact the FWO if they had a problem at work.
In the section of the survey where we asked underpaid participants about any action they had taken, we asked those who had tried to recover unpaid wages whom they contacted for assistance.
Among 4,783 participants who indicated they had been underpaid, 59% knew about the FWO and 43% indicated they would go to the FWO if they had a problem with their wages.
However, only 3% (150) of underpaid participants actually contacted the FWO.92
Clearly, simply knowing about the FWO, or being open to contacting the FWO for problems at work, does not mean that migrants who know they are underpaid will approach the FWO for assistance to recover wages or to report employer noncompliance. Underreporting of underpayment cannot simply be solved by better dissemination of information about the FWO and referrals to the FWO. Nor can businesses, universities or other service providers assume that underpaid migrants who are made aware of the FWO will report to the FWO.
Figure 14. Awareness of the Fair Work Ombudsman, willingness to go to the FWO for workplace problems, and participants who actually went to the FWO for help with unpaid wages.
Base: Participants who indicated they knew they had been underpaid in Australia and who answered the question related to awareness of the FWO and willingness to approach the FWO for a problem at work (n=4,783).
International students were less likely to seek FWO help for unpaid wages than other temporary visa holders
Among 3,837 participants who were international students at the time of the survey who believed they had been underpaid, only 3% had sought wage recovery through the FWO (noting they may have contacted the FWO on another visa). This figure was slightly higher (5%) among the smaller cohorts of participants who, at the time of the survey, were Temporary Graduate visa holders (283 participants) and Working Holiday visa holders (133 participants) who believed they had been underpaid.
Gender did not impact whether participants contacted the FWO
Similar proportions of underpaid women (3%) and men (3%) sought help from the FWO to recover unpaid wages. 5% of 44 non-binary or another gender participants contacted the FWO.
Nationality had limited impact on whether participants contacted the FWO, with a few notable exceptions
Among most cohorts with at least 50 nationals who indicated they had been underpaid, between 1% and 3% had contacted the FWO, with a few notable exceptions: no underpaid Bangladeshi nationals had contacted the FWO and slightly larger proportions of Taiwanese (8%), Thais (6%), South Koreans (6%) and Japanese (6%) had contacted the FWO.
Around half of participants who contacted the FWO recovered any of their wages
Among 152 underpaid participants who went to the FWO, 30% recovered all of their unpaid wages, 24% recovered some of their unpaid wages and 45% recovered none. We found no demographic or other characteristics that distinguished the participants who recovered some or all of their wages and those who recovered none.